Can Merit Pay and Promotion Be a More Motivational Factor for Employees Than Just the Occasional Extrinsic Reward of Employee-of-the Month Recognition

In: Business and Management

Submitted By skinnypimp
Words 1571
Pages 7
Can merit pay and promotion be a more motivational factor for employees than just the occasional extrinsic reward of employee-of-the month recognition?

Week 7-Applied Research Paper Holly GM591 Leadership and Organizational Behavior

Abstract

I. Overview of Organization The Cleveland Clinic Foundation often referred to as CCF, is a well-known “non-profit academic medical center that integrates clinical and hospital with research and education” (CCF, 2011, p. 1). CCF is also considered as the leading world class care hospital that is located right here in Cleveland, Ohio. It comes as no surprise that they are consistently voted in as the best hospital, always ranking at the top of the charts with the number one spot in patient care and service in the world. They are also continuously recognized for their excellent service by their patients and organizations that recognize excellence in comparison with other hospitals. My familiarization and experience with the Clinic has enabled me to view and compare its reward systems from both as a volunteer, an employee’s perspective; and now as an observer. My first association with the Clinic began in 1999 as a student volunteer from the John Hay High School Thematics program; who currently still partners with CCF having almost been ten years later. I have not only put in time with volunteering throughout my high school years from 1999 through 2002 in various departments of the Cleveland Clinic, but had the most amazing opportunity to be offered a position as a Biomedical Engineer through the work study program in my sophomore year. Now my relationship with the clinic is just the daughter of an eleven year employee as an outside observer. The Cleveland Clinic is one of many organizations that understand that their recognition of…...

Similar Documents

Extrinsic and Intrinsic Rewards

...Extrinsic and Intrinsic Rewards In this paper I will answer the following questions: 1. Compare and contrast extrinsic and intrinsic rewards within the workplace. 2. How have you observed extrinsic and intrinsic rewards working well? 3. How can managers and leaders improve extrinsic reward and pay for performance plan? Introduction Motivation in an organization is a key element to increase overall operational efficacy. Proper motivation keeps employees working at high productivity levels, increases morale and increases retention of valuable employees. All of those dimensions are critical to a successful operational structure. In addition, these are also central elements in ensuring that when organizational change is necessary, the conditions to make switches will be as conducive as possible to desired outcomes1 . How to motivate diversified workforces and engage staff is the subject of ongoing studies and examinations of management tactics. Motivation is facilitated by the managers and leaders of an organization and can be divided into intrinsic and extrinsic categories. Both intrinsic and extrinsic rewards when used properly motivate employees to reach optimal success in the work place. Compare and contrast extrinsic and intrinsic rewards within the workplace. Extrinsic rewards are usually financial. They are generally awarded to employees from managers in the form of pay raises, bonuses, benefits and title. These......

Words: 1231 - Pages: 5

Pay for Performance: Effect on Employee Motivation

...Pay for Performance: It’s Effect on Employee Motivation Name Course Title Professor’s Name Date Pay for Performance: The Effect on Employee Motivation Managers are continuously looking for ways to motivate their employees. Many methods have been tried and many methods have failed. Consequentially, human resource professionals and managers continue to work to develop effective performance management systems which serve to motivate employees, with an end result of improved morale and increased productivity. Designing an effective performance management program, combined with the appropriate compensation methods, can serve as tools to inspire and motivate employees to improve and/or maintain the highest levels of performance. Compensation administrators are encouraging the use of pay-for-performance plans to meet this goal. Pay-for-performance plans motivate employees to be productive and perform at higher levels by linking their pay directly to their pay. The idea behind pay-for-performance plans is that money serves to motivate employees to perform. Maslow’s theory of motivation “suggests that employee needs are arranged in priority order such that lower-order needs must be satisfied before higher-order needs become motivating” (Leonard, 2010, p. 121) with the lowest level of needs being basic biological needs and the highest level being self-fulfillment. When an individual is on the lower levels of the spectrum and trying to fulfill his/her basic...

Words: 4107 - Pages: 17

The Use of Intrinsic and Extrinsic Rewards on Improving Job Performance in an Organization

...competitively, the performance of their employees goes a long way in determining the success of an organization (Ajila and Abiola 2004). Both public and private sectors organizations are putting increasing attention on human resource management to maintain and motivate its most valuable and worthy assets, the employees. According to Catalini (2012), organizations are taking more of a proactive stance towards ensuring employees are satisfied with their place of employment and feel a level of commitment and connection to employers. Back then, employee satisfaction is often not a primary focus of an employer. Organizations routinely focus on finances, production, and pleasing customers and neglect the impact their actions or lack of action has on employee satisfaction. The consequences may be seen in products or services that are not up to standards and an increase in turnover and increase in cost for employers. Hence, finding the right balance between employee satisfaction and its enhancement of employee motivation and performance is imperative as it will have positive effects on several aspects of an organization, including lowering turnover rates and increasing productivity and profit. The use of rewards has been found over the years to be one of the management tools in the organization to increase job performance. Besides, it is common to offer employees attractive, lucrative and competitive remuneration packages. For example, an attractive reward packages has......

Words: 5061 - Pages: 21

Reward Programs

...Review 3 2.1 Introduction 3 2.2 Reward 3 2.2.1 Designing a Reward Program 3 2.2.2 Types of Reward Programs 4 2.2.3 Journal 9 4.0 Methodology 13 5.0 Findings 14 6.0 Discussion 20 7.0 Limitation 22 8.0 Recommendation 24 9.0 Conclusion 28 References 29 Appendix 31 1.0 Introduction Understanding what motivates people is necessary at all levels of management. Deci, E., Koestner, R. & Ryan, R.M. (1999) had said that motivation is generally linked to reward, and it is widely recognized that reward management is central to the regulation of the employment relationship. The reward system varies from organization to organization, and comes in various and concrete forms, including monetary or non-monetary, tangible or intangible, and physical or psychological, and these are offered to the employees as compensation for the productive work they execute. According to Jean Christofferson and Bob King (WorldatWork-2006), an effective reward system can serve the strategic purposes of attracting, motivating, and retaining employees to achieve organizational goals. A formalized corporate reward system is necessary because it appeals to capable and skilled employees to fill the available positions in a specific organization. Additionally, such method helps retain employees in the organization, hence maintaining a stable workforce with an acceptable turnover rate. Lastly, an efficient reward system also motivates employees to perform their responsibilities......

Words: 8067 - Pages: 33

Financial Rewards

...2 Background 2 2.0 Motivation 2 2.1 Definition of Motivation 2 2.2 Theories of Motivation 3 3.0 Reward System in Organizations 3 4.0 Types of pay Scheme’s 4 4.1 Payment by Result 4 4.2 Skills-based pay 4 4.3 Profit sharing 4 4.4 Performance-related pay 5 5.0 Discussion 5 6.0 Empirical Study 6 6.1 Volvo Current Reward System 6 6.2 Employee and Mangers View of Reward system in Volvo 7 7.0 Empirical Study 2 7 8.0 Conclusion 7 9.0 References 8 10.0 Appendix Page 9 1.0 Introduction 1.1 Research question Today an organizations result is highly dependent on the employees work motivation. It therefore becomes important for a company to find out what motivates its employees so that it can plan a suitable reward system and gain better results. The right and adequate combination of immaterial and material rewards can boost up an employees work motivation and enhance their commitment to the company. The aim of this documentation is to investigate and analyze how well a reward system helps generate employee motivation. More specifically it aims, to conclude that a financial reward is not an effective implementation to increasing employee motivation 1.2 Background A well designed and functional reward system is an efficient way to increase employee work motivation. The appropriate type of reward is developed in accordance to the company’s reward philosophy, strategies and policy, however, it might be challenging to find the right way to combine......

Words: 2709 - Pages: 11

Motivational Theories

...effort must lead to greater reward people will meet standards if they are closely controlled firm but fair supervision will be respected Taylor took the view that there is a right (meaning best) way to perform any task. It is management’s job to determine the right way. Workers gain from this approach because the ‘right way’ is easier and pay is enhanced as a result of increased productivity. The human relation view - originates in the work of Mayo, known as the Hawthorne Studies. The series of studies essentially concluded that the strongest motivational force behind most employees’ behaviour at work was the preservation and nurturing of social relationships with their colleagues. The main tenets of this view are as follows: people want to be made to feel valued and important people want recognition for their work people want to be controlled sensibly managers must discuss the plans they make for staff they must take any objections on board they must encourage self-regulation on routine tasks Mayo’s work leads to an approach towards people which encourages contribution and self-direction, advocating full participation on matters of significance in order to improve the quality of decisions made and the nature of supervision. Theory X and Theory Y managers Douglas McGregor proposed a Theory X and Theory Y model to explain basic human traits. Theory X assumptions are: The average human being has an inherent dislike of work and will avoid it if he can. Most people must be......

Words: 3556 - Pages: 15

Reward and Recognition

...Employee Recognition Program Handbook Department of Human Resource Management September 2000 DHRM 01/30/2001 TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION............................................................................................ 2 RECOGNITION/REWARD............................................................................. 4 PROGRAM DEVELOPMENT ....................................................................... 7 KEY POINTS TO REMEMBER - ELEMENTS OF SUCCESSFUL PROGRAM ............................................. 7 STEP- BY-STEP GUIDELINES............................................................................................................ 9 IDEAS TO HELP MEET YOUR BUDGET ................................................ 17 NO/LOW COST RECOGNITION IDEAS............................................................................................ 17 MODERATE/HIGHER COST RECOGNITION IDEAS........................................................................... 18 APPENDIX A ................................................................................................ 18 RESOURCES ............................................................................................................................. 19 Web Sites ................................................................................................................................................................................19 Magazine/Internet Articles..........................................

Words: 7089 - Pages: 29

Motivating Employees

...CHAPTER 10 - MOTIVATING AND REWARDING EMPLOYEES LEARNING OUTCOMES After reading this chapter, students should be able to: 1. Define and explain motivation. 2. Compare and contrast early theories of motivation. 3. Compare and contrast contemporary theories of motivation. 4. Discuss current issues in motivating employees. 5. |Opening Vignette – Best Practices at Best Buy | |SUMMARY | |Do traditional workplaces reward long hours instead of efficient hours? Wouldn’t it make more sense to have a workplace in which “people can | |do whatever they want, whenever they want, as long as the work gets done?” Well, that’s the approach that Best Buy is taking.1 And this | |radical workplace experiment, which obviously has many implications for employee motivation, has been an interesting and enlightening journey | |for the company. | |In 2002, then-CEO Brad Anderson (now the company’s vice chairman) introduced a carefully crafted program called ROWE (Results-Only Work | |Environment). ROWE was the inspiration of two HRM managers at Best Buy, Cali Ressler and Jody Thompson, who had been given the...

Words: 9221 - Pages: 37

Incentive as a Motivational Tool in Enhancing Organizational Performance

...TITLE PAGE INCENTIVE AS A MOTIVATIONAL TOOL IN ENHANCING ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE (A STUDY OF FIRST BANK NIGERIA PLC AND UNION BANK NIGERIA PLC) BY ONWUCHEKWA CHIDI. PG/MBA /08/53181 BEING A RESEARCH PROJECT SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENT FOR THE AWARD OF MASTER OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION IN THE DEPARTMENT OF MANAGEMENT FACULTY OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION UNIVERSITY OF NIGERIA ENUGU CAMPUS JUNE 2010 1 DEDICATION This project is dedicated to God Almighty, for his guidance and love. 2 CERTIFICATION I, ONWUCHEKWA CHIDI a Postgraduate student in the Department of Management, Faculty of Business Administration with Registration Number PG/MBA/08/53181 hereby states that I have satisfactorily completed the Project for the award of master of Business Administration (MBA) in Management. I also state that this project report is original and has not been submitted in part or full for this or any other degree of this or any other Institution of higher learning.. ________________________ ONWUCHEKWA CHIDI PG/MBA/08/53181 ______________________ CHIEF J. A. EZEH SUPPERVISOR ____________________ DR. UJF EWURUM HEAD OF DEPARTMENT 3 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT I would wish to express my profound gratitude to all the people who made it possible for me to conclude my second degree academic pursuit......

Words: 12825 - Pages: 52

Reward & Recognition

...Reward and Recognition Blue Group Liz Crane Mark Glover Annice Lappin Tim Rowler Adele Vesty The Strategic Human Resource Management strategy that we will be focussing on for this presentation is ‘Reward and Recognition’. The award winning organisation that we have researched is Schweppes Australia, winner of the 2014 Australian HR award for the Best Reward and Recognition strategy, sponsored by Solterbeck. The format of our presentation will be to: 1. define the key terms, 2. present the research and literature focussing on both corporate and not for profit organisations 3. outline the award, 4. compare and contrast the award with the research of best practice of reward and recognition. 5. conclude with the benefits and limitations and alternatives of this Strategic Human Resource Management practice. Definition For the purposes of this presentation we have used the MIT Human Resources Division definition being, “The purpose of an employee recognition program is to recognize and reward work and behaviors that support/further the mission, goals, values and initiatives (of the organisation).” While Liz Prudden of San Diego State University separates this into two main categories, “The two types of reward and recognition are easily distinguishable: Monetary, receiving dollar incentives for performance and Non Monetary (NMR), various forms of "soft" recognition. Formal and Spontaneous are additional distinctions of Reward and......

Words: 3637 - Pages: 15

How to Best Reward Employees?

... | |How to best reward employees? | | | | | |Yuling Zhang(19041245) | |2010/4/17 | |Understanding and Managing Organisations | Contents Contents 2 Introduction: 3 Total Reward and theories: 4 Intrinsic rewards more important: 5 The impacts of extrinsic rewards on intrinsic motivation: 6 Cognitive evaluation theory (CET) in motivational approach: 6 Self-perception theory in attributional approach 7 Behavioural approach: 7 Performance management, high performance working and reward strategy: 8 Other noteworthy points when rewarding: 9 Case study: 10 Conclusion: 11 Reference: 12 How to best reward the employees? Introduction: Given that people is......

Words: 3597 - Pages: 15

Employee Performance -vs- Reward System

...Employee performance -vs- reward system GM591 Leadership and Organizational Behavior Professor Vicki Boone Chartis Insurance is a world leader in insurance who can trace their roots back 90 years when an American entrepreneur named C.V. Starr founded Chartis. What began as a small insurance business grew to become one of the world’s largest companies. Their fundamental strength lies in the 40,000 employees who service more than 70 million clients around the world. Chartis delivers commercial and personal insurance though hundreds of innovative products and services. Commercial Insurance’s products and services are provided to the full spectrum of enterprises from all around the world, from large, multinational, and mid-sized companies to small business, entrepreneurs, and non-profit organizations. Chartis Insurance serves commercial, institutional and individual customers through extensive property-casualty and life insurance networks. Chartis Insurance operates through five (four core and one non-core) divisions: life insurance and retirement services, general insurance, financial services, asset management, and other operations. By the end of 2007 Chartis Insurance had assets of approximately $1 trillion, $110 billion in annual revenues, 74 million customers and 116,000 employees in 130 countries and jurisdictions. (About Us) Within Chartis Insurance I am currently a Foreign Casualty Insurance Underwriter. I protect individuals and/or organizations......

Words: 2829 - Pages: 12

Management Concepts - Employee Motivation & Rewards

...companies are faced with the challenge of increasing the level of employee commitment, job satisfaction and motivation (Greene, 2001). In this regard, it is important for companies to take into consideration the impact of employee needs, morale and expectations and to negotiate appropriate work arrangements for motivating employees as part of performance recognition. The following paper presents a discussion on the importance of employee motivation in the workplace. The discussion is mainly based on literature review and points that employee motivation is necessary for improved work performance. The paper has explored the important contributing played by work-life balance and financial incentives in improving employee motivation. The research indicates that the two factors foster loyalty by employees, increased performance and commitment, which are essential indications of motivation. The concept of Employee Motivation and Rewards Most discussions of motivation begin with the concept of individual needs – the unfulfilled physiological or psychological desires of an individual. Content theories of motivation use individual needs to explain the behaviours and attitudes of people at work. The basic logic is straightforward. People have needs. They engage in behaviours to obtain extrinsic and intrinsic regards rewards to satisfy needs (Schermerhorn et al, 2011). According to Jenkins, Mitra, Gupta and Shaw (2001) employee motivation is an intrinsic drive and enthusiasm......

Words: 2388 - Pages: 10

Factors Affect Employees’ Working Motivations

...job satisfaction in mobile telecommunication service organizations in Pakistan. In addition, the study aimed at exploring to what extent the employees are satisfied with different dimensions of their job. Research Design/Methodology: A survey-based descriptive research design was used. The study was carried on employees working in two service provider organizations of Pakistan. About 60 survey questionnaires were distributed in October, 2009 by using in person and email modes of communication. Stepwise regression analysis, correlation and p-value were used to confirming the research hypotheses. Results: As p-value is less then .05 so it can be said that the variables chosen for the study are not highly significant. The value of R square is too low that can be used for the relationship analysis of the variables. The value of beta is showing the positive relationship between the dependent and independent variables but not a strong relationship. The employees in the telecom organizations are quite satisfied by their jobs. Research limitations: The focus of the study was employees working at telecom sector in Pakistan only. Questionnaire survey was used to measure job satisfaction and work motivation. Since respondents were from two telecom organizations only and the sample was quiet small so the findings cannot be generalized to all employees of telecom sector in Pakistan. Practical implications: Considering the importance of employee’s satisfaction and its effect on......

Words: 5699 - Pages: 23

Five Key Motivational Problems of Financial Reward Schemes.

...Nowadays, an increasingly number of companies pays attention to the ways which can stimulate people. Some people think that financial methods are the best way to motivate all employees. However, financial methods of motivation are not always the most suitable way to motivate employees, and moreover not all employees. According some study, people have obvious motivation for working. On the contrary, from companies' aspect, using financial reward schemes to motivate also have several problems, summarized as follows: First, are financial rewards costs or investment? Financial rewards are salary or wages, for a company is money. Money is both cost and investment, but Managers have different opinion. Some managers who think financial rewards as company's cost set low payment standard naturally, as little as possible raise, even no raise. Other managers who think financial rewards as the investment expect to motivate employees through high payment, high benefits, and bonuses, raises. They also expect to get a return from this investment. The two views reflect the very different management philosophy, resulting in a distinct managerial effect. Second, are financial rewards needs of high level or low level? It seems money is the low-level, at least not enough noble. In fact, under normal situation, money can help people to achieve any level of Maslow's hierarchy of needs: physiological, safety, belongingness and love, esteem and self-actualization. For most people, income is a......

Words: 574 - Pages: 3