Culberton vs Brodsky: a Case for Illusory Promise

In: Business and Management

Submitted By talk2aidee
Words 909
Pages 4
Culberton Vs Brodsky: A Case for Illusory Promise

Illusory Promise is said to be a statement, a promise, and or an assurance that appears to assure a person or an entity to do or execute an action or activity and form a contract which, when properly scrutinized, leaves to the speaker the choice of performance or nonperformance, meaning that the speaker is not legally bound to act upon his/her statement. It is a situation whereby the provisions of the promise make the performance of the promise optional or completely within the discretion, pleasure, and control, of the person that made the promise. When this happens, it is believed that there has been nothing promised.

Lack of mutuality is a ground for a statement and or promise to be considered illusory promise. If an agreement grants only one party consideration of any kind, the agreement is not considered to be a binding legal contract. For instance, for my colleague to promise to pay my school fees for as long as I want to go to school is not a binding legal agreement; rather it is an illusory promise because, the subject of the promise is not such that asks for anything in return and my colleague does not receive any consideration for the promised payment, and did not form a contract.

The Agreement
Culberton had a real estate to sell and Brodsky was interested in the estate. They both had an option contract and Brodsky later decided to buy the property, but the offer was turned down by Culbertson.

From every indication, it appears that though Culberton and Brodsky did have a written agreement for the sale of land; their agreement contained no consideration. Although they had provision in their forms to write in their independent consideration amount for the buyer’s right to terminate the earnest money contract for whatever reason within the said thirty days, they did not put in any amount but zero…...

Similar Documents

Case Study Bbc vs Inforus

...Case Study BBC vs. Info R Us Dan Kelly works for Info R Us. He enjoyed his position as contract manager for the Big Bell Corporation (BBC) account. Info R Us was the subcontractor to BBC Network Systems who was the seller. BBC Network System had a mega-deal with the Chinese Government for new fiber-optic cables and wireless communications equipment across the country. Dan had worked the contract for 3 years when it came time for a contract modification. As he prepared for the contract meeting, he sat down with the new sales manager from Info R Us, Bennie Edwards. "Bennie, I know you've never dealt with BBC before, and I want to make sure that you understand what you're up against," Dan explained. Bennie leaned back in the chair. "I don't think they'll be a problem. BBC wants us to deliver our new wireless equipment earlier and provide them larger discounts. I've done stuff like this in my sleep." Dan leaned forward, "You don't know BBC. They want everything yesterday, and if you give them a centimeter, they'll take a kilometer." Dan handed a sheet of paper across the desk. "There are also some things that we need to get out of this contract change, so we have to remember that we have to hold out to support our negotiating position as well." "You think I'm going to give away the company?" Bennie asked. "I have a little more experience than that." "It isn't that at all," Dan responded. "I......

Words: 1010 - Pages: 5

Case on Parimal vs Veena

...UNIVERSITY OF PETROLEUM AND ENERGY STUDIES DEHRADUN CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE Case Study Submitted To- Submitted By- MR. RADHESHAYM PRASAD NILESH KUMAR ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR BBA.LLB. COLS SAP_ID- 500016256 UPES R.NO-R760211026 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA PARIMAL ............................................APPELLANT Vs Veena @ Bharti........................................Respondent CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION CIVIL APPEAL NO...1467... OF 2011 Bench: P. Sathasivam, B.S. Chauhan CAUSE OF ACTION (A) Appellant got married to the respondent on 9.12.1986 and out of the said wedlock, a girl was born. The relationship between the parties did not remain cordial. Thus, the appellant filed a case for divorce on 27.4.1989, under section 13of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, against the respondent. (B) Respondent refused to receive the notice of the petition sent to her by the Court on 4.5.1989 via registered AD cover for the date of hearing on 6.7.1989. Respondent/wife on 28.6.1989 was present at...

Words: 2535 - Pages: 11

Illusory Promises

...non-performance, which means that the speaker does not legally bind himself or herself to act.” That is what an Illusory Promise technically means. Illusory Promises are pretty much fake contracts. Courts will not enforce an illusory contract. Most of the time, a contract is considered illusory when it has a lack of consideration. This name came from the fact that they are pretty much just illusions of a contract. An example of this is if someone would say to you, “Maybe I will give you my car one day.” Courts will not enforce that statement as a contract because there are no definite terms used in the statement. The words “maybe” and “one day” make this an illusory promise because odds are it is not going to ever happen. This contract is not valid at all and is illusory because the promisor can choose whether or not to go through with the promise. This is not fair to the promisee because no matter what they do or give, their satisfaction is not guaranteed because of the misleading contract that they got into. Works Cited West's Encyclopedia of American Law, e. 2. (2008). The Free Dictionary. Retrieved 09 25, 2013, from Legal Dictionary: West's Encyclopedia of American Law, e. 2. (n.d.). The free dictionary. Retrieved from

Words: 256 - Pages: 2

Mathews vs. Eldridge: a Case Review

...The Mathews vs. Eldridge Case: A Review of the Significance of Due Process. In my opinion of the case Mathews vs. Eldridge was a valid claim in such that Mr. Eldridge wanted to be heard and felt as if his social security benefits had been unjustly terminated. In review of the case it is found that the Mathews vs. Eldridge case established a new precedence in deciding if due process is appropriated. The result of the case was that there should be a balance between “the interests affected and the administrative burden.” ( Mr. George Eldridge had been a Social Security beneficiary from June of 1968 up until July of 1972. His original Social Security disability benefits were noted as being because of back strain and chronic anxiety, later Mr. Eldridge contended in a written reply to the administration, after being told his benefits were to become terminated, that he had spinal arthritis and that there was enough formal documentation to determine disability benefits presented at earlier dates. The agency proceeded to terminate his benefits and informed him that he had the right to file a rebuttal within six months to be heard for reconsideration. Mr Eldridge did not do so; though Mr. Eldridge had been offered a post-termination procedure in which an oral evidentiary hearing was to be included, he instead chose to bring suit and argued that Fifth Amendment Rights had been violated. The suit claimed that Mr. Eldridge’s benefits had been terminated in......

Words: 678 - Pages: 3

Sonnys Blues vs Pauls Case

...I think people ought to do what they want to do, what else are they alive for. (49) This thought is what is reflected in both Sonny s Blues by James Baldwin and Paul s Case by Willa Cather. Both Baldwin and Cather illustrate the problem of a young man growing up and taking on the responsibility of finding out who they are and what they want out of life. In these stories the theme is most prevalent, developing the story and helping the reader form their own opinions on how they feel about their own individuality. No matter how hard someone tries to decide someone s life, it is up to the individual to decide what kind of life they want to live. In Sonny s Blues Sonny was the youngest child in his family and after his parents died when he was young his big brother made a promise that he would look after him. Unfortunately, Sonny chooses the wrong path at first and gets involved in drugs and has to go to a rehabilitation center to get better. After he gets out his brother asks him What do you want to do? (47), to which Sonny replies I m going to be a musician. (47) Sonny s brother doubts his aspirations from the beginning and even tells himself that (he) never played the role of the older brother quite so seriously before (47). Sonny s brother is a teacher and you can tell by his instincts how much he want to teach Sonny things about life in general. By playing the roles of parent, big brother, and teacher, Sonny s brother constantly stresses how he wants his brother to turn out....

Words: 615 - Pages: 3

Mktg - vs Pink Case

...Case #2 - Victoria's Secret PINK Question #1. How do you feel about the potential exposure of young girls to PINK? As a customer of Victoria's Secret I do like the PINK brand and the merchandise it offers, but as a mother of two young girls ( 9 and 11 years) I don't agree that young girls (tweens) should be exposed to the VS's PINK brand. Even though the brand is very appealing and advertised as cute and playful I believe that some of the merchandise are very explicit and too sexy for tweens. There are many items in the PINK brand that younger girls can wear but some are more appropriate for adult women. The company classifies the brand as "loungewear" that is young, hip and casual. There are quite a few items, especially panties that are definitely not casual. They are made of lace and barely have any material that covers the body. They look very controversial. Some panties also have wording that various customers may interpret differently, wording such as "tonight's the Night" on front of the panties, or "Have Fun" on the back of the panties. The PINK merchandise shown on the VS website and in the catalogs is advertised by younger models that are posing very sexy and revealing. Their looks are not for young girls to look at. The young customers will look up to the models and try to look like them and that's not right as the tween girls are too young to be exposed to such a provocative advertising ( These types of merchandise are definitely not for......

Words: 1160 - Pages: 5

Culbertson V Brodsky

...Mr. Culbertson V. Mr. Brodsky 788 S.W.2d 156, 1990 Tex. App. LEXIS 1008 Texas Court of Appeals, 1990 An illusory promise is a statement which appears to form a legal contract; however, it is vague, and lacks mutuality, providing an option for the person making a promise to have no actual obligation to perform as stated. For example, if someone says "I will make you a pie tomorrow”, this is an illusory promise, because the subject of the pledge is not being asked for anything in return and the baker is receiving no consideration for the promised activity. Because there is no consideration, there is no contract and neither party can enforce the deal (Beatty Sameulson). Mr. Brodsky signed an option contract with Mr. Culbertson, and deposited a check of $5000, representing “earnest money”, to be held by the bank for the period of 60 days. Mr. Brodsky intended to purchase the real estate property from Mr. Culbertson, if the results of an engineering study and property inspection satisfied the requirements of his intended purpose for the property. The contract required the title company to hold the “earnest money” check in escrow until the expiration of the 60 day feasibility period. If Mr. Brodsky determined the property was unacceptable within this time frame, he could terminate the agreement, at his sole election, and demand the return of the earnest money with no further obligation of either party. An option contract is a “right, which operates as a continuing......

Words: 847 - Pages: 4

Brown vs Mississippi Case Study

...In the case of Brown vs. Mississippi, three defendants Ed Brown, Henry Shields, and Yanks Ellington were charged and indicted for the murder of Raymond Stewart. Stewart was murdered on March 30, 1934 and the defendants were indicted on April 4, 1934. The defendants pleaded not guilty with their court appointed attorneys. After they were arraigned their trial was set for the following day, and convicted a day later. In the case there was absolutely no physical evidence linking the men to the murder except for their confessions. The defendants testified that their confessions were false and that they were subject to physical torture by the police and some citizens in order to obtain the confessions. When the jurors were given their instructions the defendant’s attorney were informed that if they had any reasonable doubt as to if the confessions were created through coercion or not, then they should not be used as evidence. The defendants were then moved to the Mississippi Supreme Court for a new trial to determine that if the evidence obtained against the defendants was obtained through coercion and brutality, known to the court and to the district attorney, and that the defendants were denied the benefit of counsel or opportunity to confer with counsel in a reasonable manner. The defendants filed that there was a suggestion of error and that they were denied the used of counsel when the confessions were taken violating the due process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment...

Words: 1202 - Pages: 5

Palisoc vs. Brillantes Case

...Philippine Law Cases Palisoc vs. Brillantes, No. L-29025, 41 SCRA 548 , October 04, 1971 Posted by Alchemy Business Center and Marketing Consultancy at 12:28 AM Labels: 1971, 41 SCRA 548, Civil Law Review, No. L-29025, October 04, Palisoc vs. Brillantes Palisoc vs. Brillantes, No. L-29025, 41 SCRA 548 , October 04, 1971 G.R. No. L-29025 October 4, 1971 Spouses MOISES P. PALISOC and BRIGIDA P. PALISOC, plaintiffs-appellants, vs. ANTONIO C. BRILLANTES and TEODOSIO V. VALENTON, owner and President, respectively, of a school of arts and trades, known under the name and style of "Manila Technical Institute" (M.I.T.), VIRGILIO L. DAFFON and SANTIAGO M. QUIBULUE, defendants-appellees. Leovillo C. Agustin for plaintiffs-appellants. . Honorato S. Reyes for appellee Brillantes, et al. . Villareal, Almacen Navarra & Amores for appellee Daffon. . TEEHANKEE, J.: An appeal in forma pauperis on pure questions of law from a decision of the Court of First Instance of Manila. . Plaintiffs-appellants as parents of their sixteen-year old son, Dominador Palisoc, and a student in automotive mechanics at the Manila Technical Institute, Quezon Boulevard, Manila, had filed on May 19, 1966, the action below for damages arising from the death on March 10, 1966 of their son at the hands of a fellow student, defendant Virgilio L. Daffon, at the laboratory room of the said Institute. . Defendants, per the trial court's decision, are: "(T)he defendant Antonio C. Brillantes, at the...

Words: 5201 - Pages: 21

The Netbook Case and Broken Promises Case Study

...The Netbook Case and Broken Promises Case Study The Netbook Case and Broken Promises Case Study Question 1 answer. This situation for Nicholas comes down to a very expensive “lesson learned” experience. He has a couple of options for handling this situation. Nicholas can accept the netbooks and work on trying to make them useable by the employees at the Medina Office Store, he could see if he can sell them to another business and purchase the netbooks again with Windows XP, or he can try to fight it out in court. Trying to make the netbooks useable is probably the best choice for Nicholas to handle the current situation, as the other two options will further delay getting the needed correct netbooks and will cost more money. As for Ting, the best way for him to handle the situation would be to provide the best customer service and training to the Medina Office Store, preferably at the lowest cost possible. It appears that Ting knew that Nicholas’s need was for Windows XP compatible netbooks since Ting both spoke with Nicholas directly and read his follow up letter. Legally Ting was correct the netbooks met the requirements of the RFP, but the transaction could be viewed negatively and could have an effect on future business sales. Also Ting had guaranteed that Nicholas would be pleased or given his money back. If Nicholas can document and prove he is not pleased, Ting should follow through with returning Nicholas’s money. Question 2 answer. Nicholas needs to......

Words: 1067 - Pages: 5

Walmart vs Duke Case

...BU 301 Walmart Stores, Inc v. Dukes On March 29, 2011, a case was brought to the United States Supreme Court. The case was Walmart Stores, Inc. v. Betty Dukes. This case was an appeal from the Ninth Circuit’s, which that court ultimately by narrow 5-4 decision, affirmed the district court’s decision to certify a class action lawsuit. The plaintiff class included 1.6 million women who currently work or previously worked for Walmart stores, which included Betty Dukes as the lead plaintiff. Dukes and the other employees claimed gender discrimination in pay and in promotion policies and practices in Walmart stores. Walmart is the nation’s largest private employer. The company operates more than 3,500 stores and more than one million employees at their stores. Pay and promotion decisions at Walmart are generally delegated to local mangers’ broad discretion alike any other company. In every Walmart there is a policy against discrimination in making employment decisions. Betty Dukes, a 54 year old woman at the time, was a current employee at Walmart in California. In 2000, she alleged sex discrimination. Betty Dukes had worked there for six years and had positive performance reviews. She was denied in training that she needed for advancement to a higher salaried position. Walmart and Dukes quarreled with a female Walmart supervisor and was restraint for returning late from lunch breaks in the past. Three individual plaintiffs, who were employees of Walmart joined......

Words: 855 - Pages: 4

Bosse vs Chili Case Study

...Case Name: Bosse vs. Brinker Restaurant d/b/a Chili’s Which court is making this decision? Who did what to whom? Bosse was a customer who ran out on his bill. Another patron, who is unknown, chased Bosse. During the chase the unknown patron called and informed an employee at Chili’s of the situation, who then called 911. While being chased Bosse was involved in an auto accident and was injured. What relief (claim) was sought by plaintiff in the lower court? Bosse claims the unknown patron was working on behalf of the restaurant, he therefor caused the accident which makes the restaurant liable for damages. What was the lower court’s decision? And, if applicable, the Court of Appeals’ decision? N/A Who prevailed in the lower court(s)? N/A What is the specific legal question, based on what facts, is this court is being asked to address? Did the unknown patron’s actions create an agency when they contacted Chilis? There is no genuine issue to prove Bosse claim of the patron working as an agent for Chili’s. What law(s) and specifically, which legal element(s) is (are) at issue? The common law of agency. Specifically the implied agency due to the patron pursuing the plaintiff. What is the court’s reason (interpretation) for the application of, change in, or exception to the law? There was no implied agency due to no consent, no control and there was no relationship or benefit for the restaurant, between them and the unknown......

Words: 364 - Pages: 2

Water Case and Mixi vs. Facebook

...1 750 Q = 16 150 Water case: 1. As is evident from the case, the demand for water is relatively inelastic (varying between -0.2 and -0.4). This is due to the fact that we need water in our everyday lives and we are not very sensitive to price changes because as a product water is not easy to substitute. Even so, elasticity will be slightly higher for households with higher annual consumption. This is so because the higher the consumption, the greater the opportunity for variations in quantity demanded. On the other hand, the lesser the consumption, the more basic needs it covers and the less opportunity there is to cut back on usage. 2. Rich households benefit more from a flat fee. This holds true for two reasons. First, the flat fee will be a smaller proportion from the budget of rich families. Second, the flat fee benefits more the rich because normally they possess more home appliances that use water, as well as a more lavish lifestyle (garden that needs watering, etc.), which leads to a higher overall consumption. The higher the consumption, the bigger the benefit of paying a flat fee. 3. The price elasticity is underestimated because the existence of flat flees and decreasing unit costs undermines the effect of price on quantity demanded. As stated in the case families that pay based on volume rates use 70% less water than those paying a flat fee. This means that if flat fees didn’t exist, demand would be more elastic. 4. It is provided in the case that the......

Words: 1789 - Pages: 8

Teacher vs. Student Cases with Analysis

...Prof Ed 12 Relevant Laws for Teachers . Submitted to: Professor Rodrigo Duque Submitted by: Abbie Irish M. Mendoza III-2 BECEd G.R. No. L-39275 December 20, 1933 THE PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINE ISLANDS, Plaintiff-Appellant, vs. RICARDO MENDOZA, Defendant-Appellee. In criminal case No. 4851 of the Court of First Instance of Pampanga, the provincial fiscal thereof filed an information against the herein appellee, which reads as follows: The undersigned provincial fiscal accuses Ricardo Mendoza of the crime of assault upon a person in authority committed as follows:chanrobles virtual law library That on or about September 30,1932, in the municipality of San Fernando, Province of Pampanga, Philippine Islands, the said accused, Ricardo Mendoza, being a pupil of the teacher Iluminada Tinio, did then and there willfully, unlawfully and criminally attack and lay hands upon her person, to wit: slapped said Iluminada Tinio on one of her cheeks, while she was engaged in the performance of her duties as such teacher and while she was within the premises of the high school building exercising the functions inherent in such capacity. Upon motion of the appellee, as accused in the aforesaid case, the trial court dismissed the information on the ground that the facts alleged therein did not constitute a crime but simply a misdemeanor or light felony. The present appeal was taken by the fiscal for the purpose of setting aside the order of dismissal in......

Words: 7409 - Pages: 30

Culbertson Verse Brodsky

...Culbertson verse Brodsky After reading the case Culbertson verse Brodsky, I believe that Brodsky did not give valid consideration that makes Culbertson’s promise enforceable. Culbertson and Brodsky had signed an option contract. According to Wikipedia, an option contract is promise which meets the requirements for the formation of a contract and limits the promisor's power to revoke an offer (paragraph 1). In other words, the contract must be made with the interest of both parties, and their contract was not. It was strictly in the interest of “protecting” Brodsky. The contract stated that Brodsky is to give the bank a check for $5,000 for “earnest money” to hold the land for up to six months. However, the bank was not to cash the check unless, he agreed to purchase the land. By allowing Brodsky to do so, this meant that Culbertson had to take the land off the market causing him to miss out on potential buyers if Brodsky decided that he did not want the land after he had ran his necessary test on it. It also, meant that Brodsky was able to get a “free” six month look at the land at the expense of Culbertson because Brodsky would have not loss any money if he chose not to purchase the land. Brodsky argued that the option contract was in good faith. Though the contract was made in good faith, it was made in personal satisfaction for Brodsky not Culbertson. Yes, Brodsky agreed that if the test showed the land would work he would purchase, but what if it did......

Words: 515 - Pages: 3