Meat vs Vegetarian Debate

In: Social Issues

Submitted By suzieclecton
Words 2781
Pages 12
Meat vs Vegetarian: the War of Strong Opinions

The question whether the views of people with strong but scientifically unsupported opinions should be given prominence equal to those with compelling scientific evidence in the decades-long battle of ‘conclusive evidence’ between the Meat and the Veg camp, seems to have surfaced again in the debate.

On one hand, there is always a moral choice camp for whom vegetarianism and veganism are choices of non-violence towards animals. PETA is the biggest advocate for moral vegetarianism and much alike other followers of this principle, is not too much concerned with the ultimate healthiness of the food choice, as long as it does not involve killings. “Soy sausages and “Fib Ribs to Tofurky jerky and mock lobster” that PETA is citing as its meat alternatives, do not sound too ingredient-friendly.

On the other hand, people choosing vegetarian or meat diet for its health-related advantages are faced with dire straits of scientific burden of proof because health is a long-term domain of high science.

‘Compelling scientific evidence’ appears to be a strong word sequence with almost magical powers, practically an idiom, but, of course, it has to be handled carefully. In many examples of bad or ‘yellow’ journalism, the phrase “British [American, sometimes on gets Chinese for exoticism] scientists have discovered” often validates, or at least serves as modality qualifier for the stories with unchecked or altogether invented facts.’ Trust of popular reader in omnipotent Science is of course a wonderful legacy of the European Enlightenment – the Scotts of the 17th and the French of the 18th centuries. The Enlightenment Project with positivism at its core has put The Science on the Olympus higher than that of the Greek gods. Unprecedented authority of the positivist method of science, naturally, still serves many good…...

Similar Documents

Vegetarian Diet vs. Omnivorous Diet

...Vegetarian Diet Vs Omnivorous Diet Vegetarian: a person who does not eat meat or fish, and sometimes other animal products, especially for moral, religious, or health reasons (Oxford). Evolution dictates undisputedly the fact that in order to survive all animals including human beings must consume the by-products of DNA (Evolution). Since living organisms (i.e. Plants &/or Animals) are the only provisions for DNA, their consumption is vital in securing a position in the cycle of life. For many, taking on the role of a vegetarian is far from thought. It may be because of the great difference in taste between the two that separates a person from even the slightest cooperation with the idea or the simple but vast feeling of the unwillingness to change something that’s working. Some might even argue that an herbivorous diet is no where near as healthy as an omnivorous diet. Well, the truth is, a vegetarian diet can indeed actually prove to be healthy. Once it is carefully and properly planned out, of course. In fact the design of a human’s intestinal tract, being long and all places homo-sapiens more in the category of herbivorous than carnivorous. As longer intestines allow herbivores more time to break down and assimilate tough-to-break-down plant fiber (Walker, 2006). A diet absent of meat can prove to be more advantageous than the contrary; as it consists of lower levels of total fat, saturated fat and cholesterol which allows for a lower risk of obesity, coronary heart......

Words: 1654 - Pages: 7

Meat Essay

...Eating Meat: Organic Vs. Corn Fed Vs. Grass Fed There are many debates any differing opinions going around, concerning which type of beef—or meat in general, for that matter—is the best for humans to ingest. Having these many6 different opinions and facts floating around makes the average consumer go crazy in the shopping lines. Many people simply want to know what is best for them—the healthiest option for themselves or their family. Finding this information, however, has proven to be quite a difficult task, one that does not seem to be easily completely. Contrary to popular belief, the vast amount of information, views, opinions, and statistics out there, concerning the different types of beef feed actually make the search for the truth more difficult, not easier. The information, what little fact is actually out there, is hard to decipher, due to its complicated nature, and the fact that it looks as though it was written for biologists to understand. The average shopper just wants the facts, in laymen’s terms; however, this is rarely what they find. Unfortunately, what facts they actually find ids obscured by the many opinions and views that have nothing to do with the actual facts. The simple fact remains, though: humans’ bodies are more apt to take-in and digest the type of meat that is more nutritious and able to used the most in our systems—either ads fuel, bone support, vitamins, or minerals. Many consumers now purchase grass-fed or organic beef, thinking...

Words: 413 - Pages: 2


...Association (ADA): * Vegetarian foods are a major source of nutrition for most people in the world. * Vegetarians have lower rates of heart disease and some forms of cancer than non-vegetarians. According to the ADA position paper on vegetarian diets, however, “recent data suggest that adopting a vegetarian diet does not lead to eating disorders, rather that vegetarian diets may be selected to camouflage an existing eating disorder.” Slide 1: Health benefits in becoming a vegetarian According to the ADA, vegetarians are at lower risk for developing: •Heart disease •Colorectal, ovarian, and breast cancers •Diabetes •Obesity •Hypertension (high blood pressure) Note This is because a healthy vegetarian diet is typically low in fat and high in fiber. However, even a vegetarian diet can be high in fat if it includes excessive amounts of fatty snack foods, fried foods, whole milk dairy products, and eggs. Therefore, a vegetarian diet, like any healthy diet, must be well planned in order to help prevent and treat certain diseases. Many news headlines say vegetarians live longer than meat eaters. Eating a vegetarian diet offers numerous health benefits, but some medical studies cite a few potential problems. Slide 2: Health risks in becoming a vegetarian May have intakes for vitamin B-12, vitamin D, calcium, zinc that are lower than recommended 1. Lower bone mineral density Note: While it’s possible for vegetarians to consume adequate......

Words: 342 - Pages: 2

Data on Fixed Line vs. Cellular Debate

...NT 1310-M1: Physical Networking 23 March 2014 Data on Fixed Line vs. Cellular Debate Fixed line networks were the standard up until cellular phones were introduced. Fixed lines are in almost every home and building today so people have the ability to utilize a telephone and data service. To receive or transmit data over the fixed line a modem is needed. The modem takes the digital information and turns it into tones that have been selected for the transmission over telephone network. The modem at the other end is responsible for turning the tones back into digital data. Data rates were limited until digital subscriber line (DSL) was introduced. DSL used the existing analog phone line so there was no need for new equipment other than modems that convert digital data into high-frequency tones along with a filter at the users end to keep DSL transmission from being heard on the telephone.” The pros to having a fixed line network is that it is a lot cheaper. Most providers even offer free broadband service when you are paying for other services. You also have a higher download allowance which makes it a lot easier to download large files such as movies and videos. Also allowing you to stream things from the internet and send things to family and friends much faster. Basically having a fixed line allows you to use to full potential of the internet. Fixed line networks allow for faster processing speeds and a consistent connection. You will experience less dropped calls and......

Words: 832 - Pages: 4


...never eat meat,chicken or fish, they can be energetic during the day because they take their body’s main needs from legumes,walnut,nuts,fresh fruits and vegetables.Also, a vegatarian diet avoid the cancer, descrease the risk of cardiovascular diseaseasa nd osteoporosis(bone loss,weak bones, melt of bone) The incidence of diagnosed with cancer is less on vegetarian people in comparison with people who are not vegetarian.The oxidant chemicals which are cause the cancer such as fatty acid are taken into the body by the consumption of meat. Antibiotics and hormones which are given to animals increase the carcinogenic activities of meat that people eat.However,vegetarian people keep theirselves away from these meats,also they take vegetables and fruits and legumes including vitamin E, vitamin C and antioxidant which are help to avoid the cancer.As a result, in a healthy vegetarian diet contains plenty of antioxidants known have an important place to struggle with cancer. Vegetarians has got an advantageous situation about preventions of the cardiovascular diseases. Vegetarians do not allow saturated fat ,cholesterol, homocysteine coming from animals sources to make entrance to their bodies and that is the main reason they have less risk of have cardiovascular diseaseas.According to Dr. Francesca Crowe from Oxford University,the Coronary vegetarian have 30 percent less risk of Coronary heart disease in comparison with non-vegetarian people.In conclusion, a vegetarian diet......

Words: 275 - Pages: 2

Data on Fixed Line vs. Cellular Debate

...Data on Fixed Line vs. Cellular Debate The debate over the merits of fixed line vs cellular data transmission is complex. There are many issues that define the advantages and disadvantages of both styles of communication. One obvious aspect to be considered is the need for mobility and portability. Not only is there any increasing demand in business communications, but the personal market in mobile information technology is experiencing explosive growth. With this growth come several concerns. Some of these include: 1. Security attacks when using unsecured connections. 2. Unwanted device connection (such as neighboring Bluetooth devices) 3. Reliable connections (building construction, distance to tower, etc.) 4. Lost or stolen devices. 5. Loss of service due to discharged batteries. Many advantages also exist with mobile cellular connections such as cheaper calling rates (especially on long distance calls), can double as mobile access point for laptops, and access where fixed line connections are not available. Also, cellular connections are safer during electrical storms as a direct connection to physical lines is not needed. Fixed line connections have some advantages over cellular. One advantage is the ability to make large downloads faster (although this is becoming less and less of a limiting factor with cellular connections). Currently, fixed line connections are cheaper that cellular for data transfer. Another advantage is in security. Fixed line......

Words: 435 - Pages: 2

Fixed Line vs Cellular Debate

...Fixed Line vs. Cellular Debate Quida Graham ITT Technical Institute Fixed lines offer higher data rates than cellular networks. A fixed line is cost effective for large volumes of data. Fixed lines also include cordless phones. Landlines work in most homes without a problem. You might miss place the landline; but not lose it. You don’t have to upgrade a landline as often as cellular phone. The data is delivered by telephone wires or fiber optics. The connections can be as fast as 100Mb. Landlines have more security than cellular lines. Troubleshooting and dropped calls are not prevalent in landlines as they are in cellular phones. The advantage of cellular service is mobility. You can make a phone call while shopping or walking your dog. The cost of cellular service is cheaper than a landline. You can access the internet at any time and write word documents and print later. Cellular phones are user friendly with other devices. Speed is not an issue with cellular service; the G3, G4 and now G5 are available to the public. Troubleshooting with cellular is easy because you can go to the store where you purchased the phone and get it fixed on the spot. I would recommend a business to go with a cellular solution that is offering Skype style services. You can access internet services in any location with cellular services. You can use the service with all kinds of devices. The speed would be an attractive package for consumers. References

Words: 270 - Pages: 2

Nature vs Nurture Debate

...The Nature versus Nurture Debate Sharon Turzai Western Governors University The Nature versus Nurture Debate Nature versus nurture, a debate of the influence of genetics compared to a persons’ environment has been, and continues to be a debate of scholars over many years. On one side of the argument there stands “heritability, a measure of the degree to which a characteristic is estimated to be influenced by heredity” (Wood, Wood, & Boyd, 2011, p. 247). The individuals’ environment or how, where and with whom the person was raised would be the other side of the discussion. On one hand, some believe that nature, the genetics of a person is what decides how a person shall end up in life. Many have argued that intelligence, personality, and even sexual orientation are decided by a person’s genetics. On the other hand, some have stated that it is the individuals’ environment, or nurture that molds the person. Some of course argue that both genetics and environment make up a persons’ destiny. “Today, most psychologists agree that both nature and nurture contribute to intelligence, but they continue to debate the relative contributions of these two factors” (Wood et al., 2011, p. 247). There has been much controversy regarding the nature versus nurture debate. The dispute that develops with the debate comes much from the social and political inequalities that is seems some of the research results in. There are many examples of such issues. Some individuals......

Words: 1398 - Pages: 6

Vegetarian Diet

...5 types of vegetarian The vegan This is the most limiting type of vegetarian diet. Vegans not only eliminate all animal-based foods but avoid dairy products of all types as well as eggs. While generally considered to be a healthy diet in terms of preventing disease, it takes planning to get enough protein, iron, and calcium on a vegan diet, although it’s not impossible. Many people start out with less restrictive form of vegetarianism and gradually progress to a vegan diet over time.  Lacto-vegetarianism People who adopt a lacto-vegetarian diet abstain from all meat products, including eggs, but continue to eat dairy products. The advantage to this form of vegetarianism is you’re less likely to develop a calcium deficiency due to the inclusion of calcium rich milk products. Lacto-ovo vegetarianism Lacto-ovo vegetarians avoid all meat but allow themselves to eat both dairy products and eggs. The inclusion of eggs and milk makes it easier to maintain calcium and protein levels and is, in general, an easier form of vegetarianism to adapt to, particularly if you eat out a great deal. Have you ever stopped to consider how many baked goods contain eggs and dairy products? Pescatarians One of the least restrictive forms of vegetarianism is the pescatarian lifestyle where you avoid all meat products with the exception of fish. Many people don’t consider pescatarians to be true vegetarians since they allow themselves to eat seafood. They also consume dairy products......

Words: 477 - Pages: 2

Psy/405 Klein vs. Erikson Debate

...Klein vs. Erikson Debate Jamie Salas, Jessica Borrero, Melondy Moore, Reshunna Robbins, Roxanne Luck, Shayna Parks 6/29/15 PSY-405 Patti Toler Roxanne - In this debate we are going to argue the applications of Melanie Klein’s Objection Relations Theory and Erik Erikson’s Post-Freudian Theory in regards to their describing of individual personality characteristics along with interpersonal relations. Team Klein will begin the debate: Jessica - On the positive aspects of Klein’s object theory on individual personality characteristics is how an infant’s experience can shape their future personality. One is the object of the breast, which later perceives total control and this drives satisfaction called the id. According to Burch (1988), “Good experiences or phantasies of the breast are split off from bad ones and internalized”. These experiences help shape the relationship with others in adulthood. Interpersonal relations with the object of the breast create love, comfort and gratification towards the mother, and others. A tendency to relate these feeling with others can create a good structure of positive relationships and fantasy-like quality of life. Team Erikson will now oppose: Melondy - Klein did face some criticism from others about her theory and the techniques that she used. She started her study by working with children but found out that this technique had its downfalls due to the fact that the children......

Words: 952 - Pages: 4

Data vs Fixed Line vs Cellular Debate

...Jimmy Johnson NT1310 Monday Night Unit 1 Lab 1: Data on Fixed Line vs. Cellular Debate As many as one in six American households have given up their landline and are using only their cell phone, according to Steven Blumberg, a senior scientist at the Center for Disease Control’s Statistics department. If you are among the millions of Americans who are weighing the pros and cons of landlines vs. cell phones, here are a few things to consider. Cost: The most common reason to choose a cell phone is that in most areas, the cost of a cell phone plan is lower than the cost of a landline, especially when you count the cost of a long distance calling plan. However, the “per month” cost that many carriers quote can be misleading. As you compare the cost of a cell vs. a landline, consider these factors: •Do you need any services that aren’t covered in this plan? For example, will you be taking your cell phone out of the call area (i.e. roaming)? Does the cost of your landline plan include voice mail and caller ID? •Does your cell phone plan require a multi-year contract commitment? If so, what is the cost of ending your contract? •How much time do you spend talking on the phone, and when do you make your calls? Some providers offer free incoming calls, or free nights and weekends, but those aren’t helpful if you make lots of outbound calls during business hours. •How many people will use the phone? If you have a large family, you can ensure that everyone has a cell......

Words: 786 - Pages: 4

Healthy Vegetarian Eating

...‘Healthy Vegetarian Eating!’ – Fact Sheet What is vegetarianism? Vegetarianism includes the practice of following plant-based diets (fruits, vegetables, pulses, nuts, grains), with or without the inclusion of dairy products or eggs, and with the exclusion of meat (red meat, poultry, and seafood) or some meat; abstaining from by-products of animal slaughter, such as animal-derived rennet and gelatin, may also be practiced The different types of vegetarian diets Lacto-vegetarian - avoiding: animal products - red meat, fish, poultry, eggs - eating: animal products - milk & milk products, plant products (grains, vegetables, pulses, nuts & fruits) Lacto-ovo-vegetarian - avoiding: animal products - red meat, fish, poultry; - eating: animal products - eggs, eggs products, milk, milk products, plant products (grains, vegetables, pulses, nuts & fruits) Pesco- vegetarian - avoiding: animal products - red meat, poultry; - eating: animal products - fish, eggs, eggs products, milk, milk products, plant products (grains, vegetables, pulses, nuts & fruits) Semi- vegetarians - avoiding: animal products - red meat; - eating: animal products - fish, eggs, eggs products, milk, milk products, occasional poultry (chicken), plant products (grains, vegetables, pulses, nuts & fruits) Vegan - avoiding: all animal products - eating: only plant products - grains, vegetables, pulses, nuts & fruits Fruitarians - avoiding: all animal products, vegetables & grains; - eating:...

Words: 470 - Pages: 2

Meat Consumption and Vegetarian People Should Eat Less Meat or Become Vegetarian?

...Meat Consumption and Vegetarian People should eat less meat or become vegetarian? Steven Zhou Royal Roads University Marianne Kettlewell November 26, 2015 Meat Consumption and Vegetarian People should eat less meat or become vegetarian? Throughout human history, it is clear that carnivores have dominated food culture since Primitive Society. Meat has been maintaining the development in human beings for thousands of years. Unexpectedly, as time has gone by, the meat industry has caused major environmental and health problems. For instance, livestock is now responsible for 51% of the world's total greenhouse gas emissions, which negatively affects the environment. Eating lots of meats could also adversely affect health, leading to many illnesses like Hypertension and Hyperlipidemia. Therefore, some people think we should eat less meat or become vegetarian. Despite these strong arguments, personally, I do not agree with this opinion, for reasons outlined below. From a perspective of health, a vegan diet is harmful to the nutritional balance, for instance, vegetarians are short of protein and calcium. Meat, such as beef, has abundant protein, six ounces of lean, chuck beef, braised contains 49.2 grams of protein, 505 calories and 32.59 grams of fat (Dr. Decuypere's Nutrient Charts). What is protein? Protein is a nutrient that the body needs to grow and maintain itself. Next to water, protein is the most plentiful substance in our bodies. In other words, protein......

Words: 1393 - Pages: 6


...increased. Bedside exercising, being a vegetarian has become a very popular option that people choose to achieve their goals. According to Vegetarian Times, “7.3 million Americans are vegetarians” ( Vegetarian diet provides many health benefits and helps to protect the environment. Although there are many advantages from being a vegetarian, one of its disadvantage is the lack of protein consuming. This paper will focus on both advantages and disadvantages from vegetarian diet. The first advantage of being a vegetarian is gaining many health benefits. Because vegetables contain high source of fiber and low saturated fat, eating more vegetables helps to prevent cancer. Several studies from German and England indicated that people who eat vegetables are 40 percent less likely to have cancer compare to people who eat meat (Vegetarian Foods). Vegetarian diet also helps to lower blood pressure. Back in 1900s, nutritionist discovered that a person’s blood pressure was significantly reduced after eating vegetables for two weeks (Vegetarian Foods). Moreover, vegetarian diet prevents obesity, especially for children. In 2009, American Dietetic Association stated that children who have grown up in vegetarian families generally look leaner than others (Bucking the Trend). The low fat and glucose in vegetables helps vegetarians to lower their body fat. The next advantage of being a vegetarian is to protect the environment. Meat, diary, and eggs manufactures produce......

Words: 456 - Pages: 2


...Vegetarianism is a big topic nowadays. Many people are for it, but some think that it has no point at all. Being a vegetarian, I have a big opinion on this topic. There are many benefits to being a vegetarian. For example, they usually eat healthier, have better medical benefits, and show more compassion towards animals. If you ask me, these are good reasons to become a vegetarian. Have you ever stopped to think about if what you are eating is healthy or not? Well, usually, the meat people eat is extremley unhealthy. Vegetarians who eat their fruits and vegetables consume more vitamin C, vitamin E, phytochemicals, which helps fight off desiese, and many more. Some of the meats, like red meat, have people fooled. Those who eat red meat, have a better chance of getting heart desiese, cancer, and having strokes, but many think that it is healthy for you simply because it has protein. There are numerous things that you do not know about the meats you eat. One thing that scares me about meat, is you never know what was fed to the animal, and exactly what part you are eating.. For example, McDonald's chicken nuggest are a big thing. Do you know how they are made? They completley grind the chicken, then make the nuggets out of the meat and who knows what else. In addition, many slaughter houses feed their animals steroids and antibiotics to make them grow at a faster pace. When we eat those animals, we are eating the medication fed to them. These medications are not......

Words: 484 - Pages: 2