Power and Politics: an Expert Opinion Case Study

In: Business and Management

Submitted By jrncoley
Words 917
Pages 4
Power and Politics: An Expert Opinion Case Study
Power and politics in business today has become more predominate and the tactics and maneuvers used to obtain what one wants have become more in some scenarios vindictive. While good business politics can often encourage healthy competition within a company, it can be hard to define and determine ones motivates as to whether or not they are “playing fair”. From the Harvard Business Journal the article titled “Into the Fray” written by M. Ellen Pebbles offers a fictitious scenario dealing with a common business situation.
In the article Michael is faced with many decisions that are directed by business ethics and politics, his decision to take an internal position in China raises some concern about the dependencies he currently has in New York. While his current position, work, co-workers and employees are dependents of his performance and will need to be considered in his new business endeavors, first and foremost though are the effect the international move will have on his family. Michael is married and has two young children; in the past his wife has put several of her own ambitions and work opportunities aside to allow Michael to further his career goals. This move will offer new adventures for each of them and provide opportunities of a lifetime. However, making such a drastic cultural change can also be detrimental, leaving his wife in tough position to further her career and children having to leave the stability and friends they have been thus far accustom too.
With the sudden and mysterious resignation of Lafleurs SA’s president of U.S. operations and the talked about company reorganization it is no wonder the gossip had sparked on the grapevine. Michael’s colleagues and other employees were taking semi-normal action in the current events that had transpired. While grapevines are to be expected in…...

Similar Documents

Power and Politics

...Power and Politics In social science and politics, power is the ability to influence the behavior of people. The term authority is often used for power perceived as legitimate by the social structure. Power can be seen as evil or unjust, but the exercise of power is accepted as endemic to humans as social beings. In the corporate environment, power is often expressed as upward or downward. With downward power, a company's superior influences subordinates. When a company exerts upward power, it is the subordinates who influence the decisions of the leader (Greiner & Schein, 1988). The use of power need not involve coercion (force or the threat of force). At one extreme, it more closely resembles what everyday English-speakers call influence, although some authors make a distinction between power and influence – the means by which power is used (Handy, C. 1993 Understanding Organisations). Much of the recent sociological debate on power revolves around the issue of the enabling nature of power. A comprehensive account of power can be found in Steven Lukes Power: A Radical View where he discusses the three dimensions of power. Thus, power can be seen as various forms of constraint on human action, but also as that which makes action possible, although in a limited scope. Much of this debate is related to the works of the French philosopher Michel Foucault (1926–1984), who, following the Italian political philosopher Niccolò Machiavelli (1469–1527), sees power as "a complex...

Words: 8519 - Pages: 35

Power and Politics

...Running Header: Power and Politics Power and Politics Paper Wanda F. Carter Power and Politics A collective group of people with general goals is how organizations are first established and built. In order the goals to be achieved people will need to work together and behave in a way that is governed by rules, regulations, policies and other methods that have been established by the organization. This is normally accomplished through the process of influencing behaviors. Power is a task of ties of give-and-take and politics is the establishment and process of the application of power. “Power can be defined as the capacity of one party to influence the other parties and to act as first party desires. Power can influence the behavior through compliance, identification and internationalization.” (Schermerhorn, Hunt & Osborn, 2006, pg. 2, ch. 12) Politics is “the constitution and procedure of the application of power, to affect the various parameters such as definitions of goals, directions, etc. It is the behavior of self serving that outside the normal legitimate system of influences may become illegitimate.” (Tushman, 1977, pg. 217) Power and politics have been on the forefront of organizations for centuries, and is essential to people in positions of authority. Typically, people in position are the ones who typically have the power because it is a function that is necessary to ensure they can effectively play their role as the top or figure......

Words: 913 - Pages: 4

Case Study 4 – the Politics of Performance Appraisal

...Bus5450 - Spring 2014 – Organizational Behavior Dean Cantave 2/6/2014 Case Study 4 – The Politics of Performance Appraisal This case study discusses the opinions and views of four managers at an arc-welding manufacturer in Minneapolis, MN. Max Steadman, Jim Coburn, Lynne Sims, and Tom Hamilton are managers at Eckel Industries and they all have differing opinions when it comes to performance evaluations and appraisals. They work in the manufacturing division each supervising a different department within the division. Every Friday the managers meet after work for drinks to relax, gossip, and give and receive advice about problems on the job. On this particular week they discuss performance appraisals, which they recently conducted for all of their direct reports. Each of the managers completed evaluation forms using graphic rating scales on each employee then discussed the appraisal with that employee. Throughout the discussion they give their opinions on how performance appraisals should be conducted and the flaws that exist within the current ranking system. Tom talks about how emotions play into the process and create biases when conducting evaluations, however, he believes that providing true and accurate feedback is a top priority to ensuring that the evaluations are an accurate reflection of an employee’s performance. Jim believes what he learned from a professor in college that when you sit down to evaluate an employee’s performance from a previous 12 month...

Words: 1312 - Pages: 6

The Power of Entrepreneurship Case Study

...Three Major points of the study ? 1.Disregarding the size of the enterprise ,entrepreneurship is the essence of functioning of the new businesses which gives life to modern market economies .Although some enterprises are small scale and employ lesser workers there operations contribute great amounts to the nations GDP which determines the nations prosperity. Small enterprises not only create jobs but also contribute towards promoting innovation and R &D development .like in the US small scale enterprises involve 39% of the high tech workers than any other enterprise which is why small scale enterprises should not be underestimated. 2. Framework of entrepreneur includes many features like government, R&D transfer Infrastructure, and in the modern days Venture Capitalism is one of the significant factors. Entrepreneurs are people with innovative ideas and ability to convince others to invest in their ideas. This is where venture capitalists come in to invest in the ideas of these entrepreneurs and create organizations which sole entrepreneurs would have problems to finance. 3.Churning termed by Schumpeter –the creation of new enterprises by destruction of obsolete ones is a continuous and ever sustaining procedure .Change is coexistent in society and only societies that adapt to change are dynamics ones maintaining their vital existence. Dying out of obsolete inefficient enterprises allows new innovation to replace such enterprises leading to a better economic......

Words: 333 - Pages: 2

Power and Organizational Politics

...INTRODUCTION TO ORGANIZATIONAL POLITICS POLITICS Power is the capacity to influence others through the control of instruments of reward and punishment – which can be tangible or intangible. Definitions of power abound. German sociologist, Max Weber defined power as "the probability that one actor within a social relationship will be in a position to carry out his own will despite resistance." Along similar lines, Emerson suggests that "The power of actor A over actor B is the amount of resistance on the part of B which can be potentially overcome by A." Power appears to involve one person changing the behavior of one or more other individuals – particularly if that behavior would not have taken place otherwise. Sources of Power are: (vi) Legitimate power – derived from the position e.g. kingship, managerial (vii) Reward Power – derived from control of resources e.g. promotion, recommendation, training etc (viii) Referent power– derived from association with powerful people (ix) Coercive power – uses the ability to force other people to act against their wishes through the fear of punishment. (x) Expert power – derived from the possession of expert knowledge or information that others need but have no alternative access. Politics is also the study of influence and the influential • Influence is measured on the basis of the number of shares one or a group has in the preferred values or attributes • The more values or attributes......

Words: 3129 - Pages: 13

Power and Politics

...of Contents Contents | Pages | The concept of power | 2 | Sources of power | 2 | Political strategies and tactics | 8 | What is political Behavior | 9 | What are the factors contributing to Political behavior | 9 | POLITICS: Power in action: | 11 | What are the Reality of Politics | 11 | What is Organizational Politics | 12 | What is Power? Power is the capacity to influence the behavior of others.3 The term power may be applied to individuals, groups, teams, departments, organizations, and countries. For example, a certain team within an organization might be labeled as powerful, which suggests that it has the ability to influence the behavior of individuals in other teams or departments. This influence may affect resource allocations, space assignments, goals, hiring decisions, and many other outcomes and behaviors in an organization. Definitions of power abound. German sociologist, Max Weber defined power as "the probability that one actor within a social relationship will be in a position to carry out his own will despite resistance." Along similar lines, Emerson suggests that "The power of actor A over actor B is the amount of resistance on the part of B which can be potentially overcome by A." Power appears to involve one person changing the behavior of one or more other individuals -- particularly if that behavior would not have taken place otherwise. Contrasting Leadership and Power Leadership focuses on goal achievement. It......

Words: 4019 - Pages: 17

Jabwood International Case Study - My Personal Opinion

...Jabwood International Case Analysis I. Analysis Problem: Jabwood International is experiencing a downward trend in revenue and sales and may continue this trend if change is not made immediately. Causes: Due to the financial crisis and economic downturn across the world, Lebanon has seen an almost flat performance in the real estate market driving down the prices of raw materials used in construction such as wood. Advances in transportation and technology have led to increased competition in the timber industry. A subsidiary of Jabwood based out of Saudi Arabia was closed for non-business related matters. This subsidiary, before closure, contributed almost half of Jabwood’s sales. Jabwood is a large company that has a very strict and limiting business structure. Jabwood’s physical presence remains solely in Lebanon. Jabwood relies heavily on one major supplier for approximately 60 to 70 percent of its revenue. This supplier intends to offer the opportunity to sell to other wood wholesalers, eliminating Jabwood’s exclusivity. Possible Alternatives: In order to increase revenue and sales, Jabwood International has many options. In my opinion, the only feasible options would include expanding their business into two countries: Saudi Arabia and China. Expanding into the Saudi Arabia market is a very enticing solution for many reasons. Saudi Arabia does not have its own wood supply and therefore relies heavily on other countries for this need. Jabwood has had......

Words: 863 - Pages: 4

Organizational Influence of Power, and Politics

...Organizational Influence of Power, and Politics October 5, 2013 Abstract In researching power and politics, you find that they play a very key and large role in how the world works. This is especially true in the world of business. These influences govern how everyday decisions are made, and even how employees interact with one another. In businesses both large and small, the impact of power and control depends completely on the individuals using it and what their long-term goals are. Ultimately politics may directly influence who has the overall power and determine what the culture of the workplace will become. This paper demonstrates how the sensitive uses of power and politics affects our everyday lives. It also shows recognition to the importance of personalities, diversification, and fair power distributions, and how these traits can ultimately improve the overall quality of organizational life. Introduction Power and politics, two substantial and critical components of business, people desire to have the achievement and preservation of power, especially to wield the art of its influence. Humans are by nature competitive and anyone can see that competition surrounds us everywhere in the business world. Those who desire great success, the ability to have large incomes and social influence drives many people. Some people more than others perhaps get caught up in the competitive nature of the business world.......

Words: 3090 - Pages: 13

Case Study Power and Leadership

...Benjamin Genous DeVry University Week 6 Assignments –Case Study Management 303 1. Brief describe the five kinds of power available to leaders and/or managers. I. Reward power, means an employee believes they are going to get some type of reward for doing their job. The reward could be pay, days off, etc. The employee believes the reward will be coming from the supervisor. II. Coercive power is a supervisor intimidating an employee to do the work or they can be fired or demoted. This can be compared to someone having a power trip complex. III. Legitimate Power, does an officer believe that the orders being given are true even if they may be coming from a higher power that does not normally give out orders to the police. An example used is an officer receiving powers from the Chief of Police and the commanding officer follows through to make sure their officers are conducting the instructions. The officer believes in his commander as he works with them all of the time and although the Chief is the highest manager, the officer knows that the commander is the one who will be making sure follow through takes place. IV. Referent power is when one person has an attraction somehow to the person giving the power. The individual will basically do anything the person with power says because the attraction is so strong. An example could be a group of teens with one teen just trying to become one of the members and they tell him to jump off a bridge. The......

Words: 2258 - Pages: 10

Power and Politics

...POWER AND POLITICS Power and politics play a important role in business or an organisation, from governing how decisions are made to how employees interact with one another. In a business big and small, the impact of power depends on whether employees use positive or negative power to influence others in the workplace. Politics may directly influence who has the power and determine whether the workplace encourages productivity. Positive power in an organization involves encouraging productivity. This includes giving employees the power to make decisions, rewarding employees for strong performance and appointing employees who perform strongly to supervise other employees. Positive power builds employee confidence and motivates employees to work harder. Negative organisational politics may be very destructive for an organisation.Negative politics includes the use of subversive methods to promote a personal agenda which may undermine organisational objectives, distract away from organisational goals and compromise the interests, cooperation and fulfilment of other employees. Such tactics may include filtering or distortion of information, non-cooperation, allocating blame,dishonesty, obstructionism and threats. In the case of Thomas Green, Frank Davis had a negative politics and power over Green which landed him in trouble over his job and he was not able to perform to his potential. Green failed to maintain a positive relationship with Davis , which he had with Mc Donald......

Words: 299 - Pages: 2

Luotang Power Case Study

...Introduction This case study Luotang Power: Variances Explained is mainly concerned with a study of variances that will show the changes in performance in the company and the external environment that is not within the power plant’s control. The Luotang Power Company (Luotang) is a 600 Mega Watt (MW) coal fired power plant located in the Hubei Province, China. Luotang first started in 1997, when the Provincial Planning Commission, working on behald of the Hubei Provincial Government, had solicited bids from international power developers to finance, design, build, and poerate a 600MW coal-fired power plant. The project was contracted on a Build Operate Transfer (BOT) Basis, that meant that the power plant would be given to the Hubei Provincial Government after 20 years of operation at no cost. Luotang was mainly rural in nature but development quickly increased when the power plant opened. Luotang is wholly owned by an American independent power producer. Luotang’s parent company is known as China Hua Tong Power (HT Power). It’s primary customer is the Hubei Provincial Power Company (HPPC) and their main coal supplier was the Pindingshan Coal Company (Pindingshan). Tan Min Yi has been the general manager of the Luotang Power Company since 2002. In this case study, it talks about how Tan has to make a presentation to the Board of Directors of Luotang’s parent company, that is HT Power about the results received in the 2011 Report of Operations. He is concerned about what...

Words: 3218 - Pages: 13

Power Politics

...Special articles Power Politics Process of Power Sector Reform in India Power sector policy in India appears to have locked itself into adverse arrangements at least twice in the recent period. The first was when agricultural consumption was de-metered and extensive subsidies were offered; the second when Independent Power Producer contracts with major fiscal implications were signed by the State Electricity Boards. A third set of circumstances, with the potential for equally powerful forms of institutional lock-in, appears to be in the making with the reproduction of the Orissa model on the national scale. This paper provides an analysis of the social and political context in which power sector reforms have taken place in India. While a state-led power sector has been responsible for substantial failures, is the design of the reformed sector well aimed at balancing efficiency and profit-making on the one hand and the public interest on the other? The discussion of the forces and actors that have shaped the reform processes is intended to contribute to an understanding of how the public interest can best be served in the ongoing effort to reshape the power sector. NAVROZ K DUBASH, SUDHIR CHELLA RAJAN I Introduction he electric power sector in India is in a state of upheaval. Over the decade of the 1990s, the long-held belief in public ownership and operation of this critical sector has been eroded. In its place has emerged a growing vision of the sector organised......

Words: 27705 - Pages: 111

Power and Politics

...POWER & POLITICS TAKE AWAY POINTS • Power is the actionable capacity to get others to do what you want. • A deeper notion of power: power is the actionable capacity to get others to want what you want. • Three faces of power: position power (where you are); expert power (what you know); relational power (who you know) • Relational power in its lesser form is networking power (who you know) and in its most exalted form, it is referent power (who looks up to you) • Power is a convertible currency; paucity in one form can be made up with abundance in another. PP((EP ((RP ((PP • Power can also be freshly minted. Look for holes in the structure (the lack of fit between strategy and structure) and fill them in with your expert power and/or referent power to create fresh bases of power. • Politics arises out of diverging goals. Politics leads to conflict the resolution of which is always political. Politics is not a flaw in design but part of the human condition. • Even with apolitical managers, when each department is given in its own goal, conflict will arise. Such functional conflict cannot be designed away. There are no structural solutions but only political resolutions. • A common culture is a great conflict –reducer. But culture takes years to fully flower. • Position power is the lord of the rings when the markets and technologies are stable and predictable. In placid times, position power is where real power is. •......

Words: 579 - Pages: 3

Power and Politics

...Power can be defined as the ability to get a person to do something wanted by another person. Power can be seen as exerting control or influencing people. Power puts people in position of authority that controls and affects the employees of an organization (Brown, 2010). People use power on people for different purposes to guide and direct their employees for higher purposes and to conform to the values of the organization; but also to achieve the goals of the organization. Power can be viewed from different aspects, power based on reward purposes, in situation where employees exert their power by rewarding their employees based on their performance whether good or bad. There is coercive power that a manager uses to deny or administer punishment simply to exert and control people in the organization although depends largely on the organization and the scope of the manager’s power. Legitimate power, this kind of power is the authority normally vested in a manager to control the behavior of the employees, based on the values, beliefs and structures of the organization. These three forms of power briefly discussed above played out itself in the case of Enron. Where Enron could have exerted influence or control for the overall interest of the organization, they started pursing personal interest by diverting into business transactions that was of unquestionable nature which resulted in loss. The interests of the employees were threatened if they have in possession......

Words: 935 - Pages: 4

Power and Politics

...Power and Politics An individual sets out in life, and in work, to achieve his or her own goals, and to promote his or her own interests. Therefore, in a hierarchal setting of an organization, individuals will naturally contend for their own interests. Aided by the use of personal power, politics, influence, and empowerment, many individuals achieve their goals within organizations. Through analyzing power and politics in the workplace and organization, one may understand the organizational behavior that is touched by power and politics in the workplace (Robbins & Judge, 2009). Leadership Practices that Influence Organizations A key organizational management and leadership practice that influences an organization is the exhibition of power and the resulting influence that exhibit of power has on organizational behavior. According to Schermerhorn, et. al., “Power is the ability to get someone else to do something you want done, or the ability to make things happen or get things done the way you want. The essence of power is control over the behavior of others” (p. 214, 2008). In contrast to power, which is the energy behind making people behave in a certain way, “influence is what an individual has when he or she exercises power, and it is expressed by others’ behavioral response to that exercise of power” (Schermerhorn, et. al, p. 215, 2008). Together, power and influence in an organization or workplace are fundamental behavioral practices that influence an organization...

Words: 1105 - Pages: 5