Summary of Critical Approach to Reality

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By carolthomas
Words 678
Pages 3
Critical Approach
View of social reality
1. Social reality is multi-layered.
2. Social reality presents us with a façade. There are more dimensions to social reality than initially appear to us. It is crucial to move from the surface structures (external appearance) to the underlying mechanisms by which social reality is maintained
3. We need to penetrate the layers of social reality and uncover the underlying relationships that determine the real characteristics of society
4. These relationships are the mechanisms that result in inequality and exploitation within a society, but they are frequently masked by external appearances
5. We do not ordinarily see the real, exploitative nature of society because we perceive it through a framework constructed for us by institutions such as the mass media, serving the interests of the wealthy and powerful in society
6. Our attention becomes diverted from the real problems of society towards a focus on entertainment and frivolous fixation on the doings of movie stars etc
7. We are lead to believe that the inequalities of the world are natural, and there is nothing we can do about them
8. A false consciousness is created when people accept the situation as being natural and therefore unconsciously reproduce the social structures that govern them
9. Only when the illusion of the social reality as it presents itself is exposed and the underlying tensions and contradictions become apparent that the full potential of human creativity and agency can be unleashed
10. The awareness created by exposing the false consciousness enables people to reflect on how they are both products and creators of social reality
11. Social reality therefore becomes a human construction with more than one possibility
12. Once this awareness is created, the transformation of social reality is possible
13. Although human beings have…...

Similar Documents

Critical Essay Analysis Within a Cultural Studies Approach

...organizations. Symbolic Interaction perspective: Positions that to understand society its necessary to understand the connotation of people’s actions and beliefs. At the moment of discussing society and its organizations, despite the sociological perspective used there are interconnected factors to be considered: Technology, politics, economy, values and beliefs. (Ray 2007) In the critical essay The Crisis of Public Values in the Age of the New Media, Henry A. Giroux’s discourse on the control of large corporations over the economy and how this affects the values of democracy, having as a result an individualistic attitude of the American people towards important factors that affect them as a society. Giroux explores the different uses of new media and its relation to the economical crisis and the essence of a democracy under a neoliberal setting, arguing that public education has to be the main instrument for a better comprehension and exploitation of the new media which capacity to reach and influence the masses is vital for the perception of a functional democracy. Likewise, Douglas Kellner, on his critical essay The Media and the Crisis of Democracy in the Age of Bush-2, analyses and exhibits the consequences for democracy caused by the media deregulation and nearly absolute control of the mass media outlets by corporations in the US and globally. As an example, he addresses how the omnipresent support by the media conglomerates lead to the election of president......

Words: 1540 - Pages: 7

Critical Summary

...Critical Summary of “Fat Merger Payouts for CEOs” Monterey Institute of International Studies ADVANCED RHETORIC AND GENRE EAPP 8456 Xiaofei Lai
 October 13, 2013 In “Fat Merger Payouts for CEOs,” Emily Thornton (2005) criticized the top CEOs for taking advantage of Golden Parachutes agreement to seize huge profit from merger. The author quoted a string of the latest news to illustrate an increasing number of famous CEOs benefiting from merger-payout provisions. In addition, Thornton indicated that this trend has negatively influenced the whole financial market. This article was timely because golden parachutes became a hot issue among CEOs when it was published; and it alarmed CEOs and corporations to think twice before taking such actions. However, Thornton failed to thoroughly declare the positive effects caused by such agreements, or fairly compare the benefits those CEOs created for their companies against their compensation. This article was published after many famous executives gained a huge amount of compensation when their companies changed hands. The most representative example was James M. Kilts, Gillette’s CEO, who obtained about $188 million when Gillette was acquired by consumer-products giant Procter & Gamble Co. Compared with Kilts’ annual salary of $23million, this compensation went far beyond the norms. Similarly, Willian W. McGuire acquired $162 million by selling UnitedHealth, while Robert L. Nardelli was promised compensation valued at......

Words: 737 - Pages: 3

The Critical Approach on the Mackenzie Valley Pipeline Inquiry

...The critical paradigm recognizes the social construction of knowledge, defined in a manner which suites the interests of the elite groups in society(Travers, 2008). Therefore, true objectivity can be found in the discourse of the marginalized groups(Travers, 2008). The goal of this paradigm is to provide a voice for the marginalized groups, addressing the issues of social inequality, and work towards making reparations, in hope of a reshaping of our society(Travers, 2008). In the case of the Mackenzie Valley Pipeline Inquiry, the critical paradigm addresses the conflicts between the differing native and elite viewpoints. Critical ontology emphasizes that reality is socially constructed by the elite groups in society, supporting their position of power, resulting in conflict as the marginalized groups resist(Travers, 2008). Berger’s report recognizes the conflict between the views of the elite groups, who run the oil and gas companies, and those of the native people. The elite groups purport that the development of the pipeline, and the associated ventures, would benefit not only the economy but the native people who would have jobs and be able to join the wage economy(Berger, 1988). They attempt to create a perception, in which the native people would benefit from joining the rest of society, using the proposed development as a means of integrating them. Berger, who appears to follow a critical ontology, voices the opinions of the natives in his inquiry. Louis Frost’s......

Words: 570 - Pages: 3

Critical Summary

...female differences lead to distrust. Although Horney’s theories do explain why certain problems in relationships do occur, the subtle differences in thought and experience between males and females may cause disagreement, but do not necessarily lead to distrust as she implies. In fact, most difficulties in relationships can be overcome when both parties learn to respect each other’s opinions, allow each other flexibility, and learn to cherish the reasons they were attracted to one another in the beginning. Lead: Transition: Bridge: Transition: Thesis: Objective Summary: Horney believed that childhood experiences, cultural practices, and religious beliefs all contributed to the distrust between the sexes. She began her speech by suggesting…. This section must summarize Horney’s views. You may not give your opinion! Critical Evaluation: This section begins with a restatement of your thesis. Although men and women will inevitable have disagreements and some of their struggles may be caused by the baggage they carry with them, most couples can overcome their differences and develop meaningful relationships. This section must have at least three paragraphs, one for each point identified in your thesis. Conclusion: Do the differences between males and females lead to distrust? Is this distrust of such a magnitude, that the relationship is doomed? Although Horney does point out......

Words: 309 - Pages: 2


...Sample essay Year 10 Philosophy What is the best way to relate to reality; control it or give up one’s desire to control it? I am going to argue that it is not necessary to give up one’s desire to control reality, but one must be realistic about how much of it one can actually control. I will focus especially on the lessons we can learn about this from the movie The Truman Show. At the outset, we need to distinguish between reality and imagination. Our brains have the remarkable ability not only to hold pictures of what has happened, but also to create pictures of what we think will happen, or could happen. This is our imagination. Without imagination, we would not be able to think sensibly about the future. Our imagination allows us to project ourselves into the future. But on the other hand, even though our imagination gives us a mental construction of the reality around us, it is not that actual reality itself. Let’s face it, there are thousands of things happening in the world around us that we do not know about and cannot imagine. Truman in The Truman Show has no idea what sort of machinations Christof is engineering to shape his life. All the people around Truman are acting. His so-called wife is an actress who is being paid to act as his wife. Truman, at first, cannot imagine this is true. He cannot imagine that Marlon is not ‘really’ his best friend, or that what Marlon says to him is actually being set up through an earpiece, with the words first being......

Words: 1146 - Pages: 5

“a Critical Assesment of Religion Today in the Philippines: Reality and Challenges; Weaknesses and Oppurtunities”

...RONIE BOTONA RESEARCH AND METHODOLOGY I Professor: Fr. Dave Capucao “A CRITICAL ASSESMENT OF RELIGION TODAY IN THE PHILIPPINES: REALITY AND CHALLENGES; WEAKNESSES AND OPPURTUNITIES” Religion is humanity’s way to be in connection with the divine. It can be traced centuries ago. In the Philippines, religion existed already during pre-colonialization. However it was only during the colonialization period that religion becomes a power to reckon and established its significance to the Filipino people regularly. Today our country has been open to any religious practices. In a recent statistics Roman Catholic is the most numbered among other religious practices. More than eighty percent of the population are Catholics, this is because it is the religion brought by the Spanish colonialists who stays in the country for over three hundred years. Aside from other Christian denominations other religions also were able to establish their presence in the country. There are Muslims, Buddhist, Jews and many others to mention, and this is because of the freedom given with regards to religious practices. Looking upon the past and even until now, religion has always been the subject of many criticisms. The Muslims in the south were considered subversive due to their demands that were not meet by the government, resulting to war and bloodshed. This has been a perennial problem for many years. Although this was more on the political aspect but religion plays a vital part. Muslims are......

Words: 806 - Pages: 4

Insider Trade: a Critical Approach

...FLORIDA INTERNATIONAL UNIVERSITY - CHAPMAN GRADUATE SCHOOL OF BUSINESS | INSIDER TRADING | A CRITICAL APPROACH | | Juan Guillermo Gonzalez | 12/20/2014 | This academic document in intended to make an analytical approach of insider trading in the U.S. It will also discuss the European case and how it compares to the U.S. Finally, it will describe international implications of insider trading and the cooperation among nations. | TABLE OF CONTENT Page Introduction …………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 4 Insider Trading – Opposing Viewpoints ……………..………………………………………………. 5 Insider Trade in the United States .………………………………………………………………………… 7 Insider Trading in the E.U ……………………………………………………………………………………. 9 Comparing the U.S. and the E.U ……………………………………………………………………….. 10 International Cooperation …………………………………………………………………………………… 11 Conclusions ………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 12 End Notes …………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 13 INTRODUCTION The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission defines insider trading as both legal and illegal conduct of corporate insiders in relation with buying or selling securities in their own companies . When corporate officers, directors, or employees trade securities within their firm, they are required to report such activities to the SEC. However, some individuals take advantage of their privileged position; having access to nonpublic, material information about the security,...

Words: 3358 - Pages: 14

Critical Thinking- a Summary or Articles

...A summary and discussion of articles; Goleman, D. (1998, fall). The emotional intelligence of leaders. Leader to Leader, 10, 20-26 And McCrimmon, M. (2005, January) Thought leadership: a radical departure from traditional, positional leadership. Management Decision, 43 (7/8), 1064-1070 Summary 1 Goleman, D. (1998, fall). The emotional intelligence of leaders. Leader to Leader, 10, 20-26 Leadership skills can be derived from various angles and most organizations have a certain style of leadership. Most of these styles come from studies and patterns of growth. Goleman (1998), in this article explains with illustrations how leadership should be construed and how one’s emotions play a huge role towards an effective style of leadership. The way you feel the type of person you are and the actions you take are essential in leadership skills. Leaders in top positions in various organizations have great credentials to show for it but like Goleman pointed out, there are some that lead mainly on what they have studied, that is, their technical expertise. Hence, they are not open to emotionally leading that organization. Our emotions are who we are, they are imbedded in us. Goleman, goes further to give in-depth illustrations as to how the human brain is linked to what feelings we feel, be it happy or sad, regret or anger. Thinking your actions through before voicing them out has a lot to do with our emotions. Our thinking faculty and the emotional part of our brain......

Words: 1939 - Pages: 8

Augmented Reality

...Augmented Reality: Linking real and virtual worlds A new paradigm for interacting with computers Wendy E. Mackay Department of Computer Science Université de Paris-Sud ORSAY-CEDEX, FRANCE E-mail: ABSTRACT A revolution in computer interface design is changing the way we think about computers. Rather than typing on a keyboard and watching a television monitor, Augmented Reality lets people use familiar, everyday objects in ordinary ways. The difference is that these objects also provide a link into a computer network. Doctors can examine patients while viewing superimposed medical images; children can program their own LEGO constructions; construction engineers can use ordinary paper engineering drawings to communicate with distant colleagues. Rather than immersing people in an artificiallycreated virtual world, the goal is to augment objects in the physical world by enhancing them with a wealth of digital information and communication capabilities. KEYWORDS: Augmented Reality, Interactive Paper, Design Space Exploration, Participatory Design INTRODUCTION Computers are everywhere: in the past several decades they have transformed our work and our lives. But the conversion from traditional work with physical objects to the use of computers has not been easy. Software designers may omit small, but essential, details from the original system that result in catastrophic failures. Even the act of typing is not benign: repetitive......

Words: 5459 - Pages: 22

A Systematic Approach

...A Systematic Approach to Writing and Rating Entrepreneurial Business Plans KEVIN HINDLE AND BRENT MAINPRIZE KEVIN HINDLE is a professor of entrepreneurship at the Australian Graduate School of Entrepreneurship, Swinburne University of Technology. Melbourne, Australia. BRENT MAINPRIZE is the core professor of entrepreneurship in the Faculty of Management at Royal Roads University in British Columbia, Canada. T here is a small but growing b o d y of research that details many desirable attributes a n d qualities that, at a general level, any entrepreneurial business plan should contain. It is a reasonable proposition that this research, and any principles it may contain, can and should provide the basis for a systematic approach t o b o t h the writing and evaluation of entrepreneurial business plans. Despite this, the majority of entrepreneurial business plan writing and evaluation is unsystematic—if systematic is taken to mean "based o n empirical evidence and developed theory." T h e vast majority of the a b u n d a n t literature on " h o w to write a successful business p l a n " is n o t research-based (Hindle [1997]). T h e espoused criteria of its authors far o u t weigh the formal application of the k n o w n attributes of successful ventures (Hindle and Mainprize [2002]). This article seeks to articulate a research-based system for assessing the c o n t e n t quality of e...

Words: 9124 - Pages: 37

Critical Thinking Discussion & Summary

...Critical Thinking Discussion & Summary Tina Cullors PHL/320 February 29, 2016 Bridget Peaco University of Phoenix Critical thinking is a way of making decisions both personally and professionally. Without critical thinking our decision making would all be knee jerk reactions and would cause chaos in your life. In discussion we will have identified what is critical thinking by identifying the premise and how we arrived to the conclusion. I define critical thinking as a process of how to analyze and evaluate the question, topic of conversation or situation, before forming an opinion or just reacting. Being able to make a clear judgment. A critical thinker is someone that does not make a conclusion on an instant with information presented. A critical thinker analyzes the information, and obtains necessary information to support the premise. Critical thinking is importation because you obtain an amount of information to make an argument that your find to be true that brings you to your conclusion with a convincing argument to justify your claim. I use critical thinking both in my personal and professional life. For example, if I am thinking of buying a new car I have to look at not how my decision will just impact my finances now but how my decision affects me long term; like can I afford to take money from my savings for the down payment and what will payment be for 36 or 48 months. As for my work when I am modernizing a school......

Words: 384 - Pages: 2

Midterm Critical Summary

...Running head: MIDTERM CRITICAL SUMMARY Midterm Critical Summary El Kihal Mohammed Al Akhawayn University 1 MIDTERM CRITICAL SUMMARY 2 The first six chapters discussed in-class included the comparison methodology in political systems, in addition to the political attitudes and behaviors in relation with the ethical foundations of politics. Furthermore, it included an introduction to political ideologies with a focus on the democratic ones. Moreover, it showcased the development of the modern state, along with some key concepts in politics such as constitutions and processes such as pressure groups and social movements. Before engaging in comparing political systems, it is imperative to be aware of the comparison methodology used for this kind of social science. The scientific method used in social sciences is based on the empirical method which includes several steps, of which the most important are: the formulation of the hypotheses after asking curious questions related to a topic of interest - the data collection - the data analysis - the results’ interpretation related to the questions raised. Looking at the political attitudes of people under a specific political system helps to understand the political systems, but what is the reason behind that? Simply because looking at the political attitude of every individual might prove itself to be impossible, so social scientists started analyzing the general trend in the political attitudes......

Words: 1054 - Pages: 5

Critical Review and Summary - a New Mandate for Hr

...  A  New  Mandate  for  Human  Resources   Article  Summary  and  Critique   Human  Resource  Management             Article  Summary:  A  New  Mandate  for  Human  Resources     HR’s  role  in  an  organization  has  been  perceived  as  peripheral  at  best,  and  value  sapping   at  its  worst.     In  today’s  world,  when  most  of  the  processes  &  systems  can  be  copied  thus  rendering   no  sustainable  advantage  in  long  term,  companies  can  majorly  differentiate  themselves   only   by   building   its   intellectual   capital   (employee   competence)   &   organizational   excellence  (organizational  capabilities)  –  which  are  very  hard  to  copy.  HR’s  contribution   to  achieve  this  is  vital.       It   is   in   this   light   that   HR’s   role   &   responsibilities   needs   to   be   relooked   &   redefined   to   extract   meaningful   contribution   from   HR.   To   achieve   this,   both,   senior   management’s   &   Line   manager’s   expectations   from   HR,   and   HR’s   expectations   from  ......

Words: 1650 - Pages: 7

Executive Summary of Ed Vos and Ben Kelleher - Mergers and Takeovers: a Memetic Approach

...Vos, E and Kelleher, B: Mergers and Takeovers: A Memetic Approach. Motivation & reason for the paper and how it fits into the overall context of the literature: In the following paper the authors describe a new understanding of the motive phenomena for manager’s initiating M&As. Previous research strongly agrees with the stance that M&As are not a financially sound investment for companies, however, it seems that managers are willing to continue to practice M&As regardless of the negative long-term effect it will have on both the acquiring and target company. This goes against the theoretical view that managers are there to increase the value of shareholders. If managers understand this, their human behaviour to continue with M&As is irrational and can’t be explained by some mathematical model. Vos and Kelleher agree that the traditional theories and models of finance are irrelevant in describing managerial motives (particularly towards M&As), as it is the human behaviour that we must study. Their thesis is that managers are not acting so as to maximise shareholder wealth (agrees with agency theory) and their primary motivation behind M&As is to gain power. The data and methodology used by the paper: This diagnostic paper provides a literature review of previous research and then looks forward by applying behavioural ideas of ‘memetics’ to explain the motivation behind managers’ actions. The results of the paper and meaning of the results, in...

Words: 472 - Pages: 2

Critical Summary

...Critical Summary Frisby, B. N., Byrnes, K., Mansson, D. H., Booth-Butterfield, M., & Birmingham, M. K. (2011). Topic avoidance, everyday talk, and stress in romantic military and non-military couples. Communication Studies, 62, 241-257. Birmingham, Booth-Butterfield, Byrnes, Frisby and Mansson, (2011) focused on everyday talk, topic avoidance and stress of those romantically involved in military relationship and those involved in non-military relationships. The first key opponent is topic avoidance along with the hypothesis; Military couples will engage in more topic avoidance than non-military couples (Birmingham, Booth-Butterfield, Byrnes, Frisby and Mansson, 2011). In an outside study, researchers Merolla and Steinberg conducted interviews with military partners who tend to disclosed information in regards to pre-deployment to avoid talking about the negative issues and distractions that occur when communicating with their partners. Researchers found that wives withhold information from their military partners to protectively buffer them from stressors that may add to the occupational stress the military partners already experienced. Topic avoidance is often commonly seen in any romantic relationship, but research shows it’s mostly common in those who are involved in a romantic military relationships (Birmingham, Booth-Butterfield, Byrnes, Frisby and Mansson, 2011). The second opponent is everyday talk, which consists of regular conversations between......

Words: 1079 - Pages: 5