Voip – Deregulation Versus Anti-Competitive Conduct

In: Computers and Technology

Submitted By money4mom
Words 4392
Pages 18

This paper will focus on Voice Over Internet Protocol (VoIP) and the deregulation versus anti-competitive conduct. In Section I we will discuss the history of VoIP and how it has developed into a standard communication device using traditional telephone lines and tech savvy software. This will be an overview of what the primary intentions for inventing the software and who the pioneers were that patented and launched this successful tangible apparatus, which is used by over 6 million in the United States and an undefined number throughout the world.

Section II is a thorough analysis of economic implications for two popular VoIP services companies in the United States: Skype, Internet based software free to users who have a personal computer and Comcast, a telecommunications corporation that has become the leader in offering bundled services that includes VoIP. The discussion will revolve around the issue of regulation and deregulation of the service and the economic impact that it has on consumers and today’s market. Sections III & IV are a detailed comparison and contrast of the regulation and deregulation for the United States versus India, Canada and the Philippines and the affects of VoIP from an economic standpoint. This will be an analysis of the proponents and oppositions of regulation competitive value and how regulation is allowing states to make decisions and maintain control over VoIP. Section V is the conclusion that will answer the question as to whether or not it is better to regulate or let competition run its course. We take a stance on how the 1996 Telecommunications Acts is not the ideal prototype for regulating VoIP and why we feel that regulation and/or deregulation should be in the public interest.

I. The History of Voice over Internet Protocol

The first Voice over IP Protocol’s used to carry voice…...

Similar Documents


...The internet is fast evolving into a universal communication network. Among them, telephony is an application of great importance. Voice over Internet Protocol, commonly known as VoIP, is a technology used for the transmission of voice information using the Internet Protocol (IP). VoIP simply means running a telephone service over broadband connection. VoIP allows the sending of voice information in a digital form using packets over packet-switched networks as opposed to the traditional circuit-committed protocols of the Public Switched Telephone network (PSTN). Traditionally when one wishes to make a phone call, a call is placed using a telephone that is connected to a circuit-switched network. In a circuit switched network, network resources are static; the network resources are allocated from the sender to the receiver before the start of the voice transmission. Two points are connected in both directions thus creating a "circuit". The resources remain dedicated to the circuit during the entire transfer and the entire voice transmission follows the same path, this is the foundation of the PSTN. The basic principle in which the VoIP works is known as ‘packet switching’. Instead of sending a continuous stream of bytes, in VoIP, the bytes are sent only in packets. These bytes are routed through a chaotic network, instead of a dedicated line. The entire process is known as packet switching. In packet switching, the connection is opened for only a brief instant, just......

Words: 460 - Pages: 2


...Voip and Ip Telephony Implementations [pic] VoIP and IP Telephony: Planning and Implementation Table of Contents Executive Summary………. Legacy Telephony Technology………. Public Switched Telephone Network (PSTN) ………. IP Technology Solution Overview………. What is VoIP and how it works?.......... What is IP Telephony? ) ………. Benefits of IP Communications over a Converged Intelligent Network) ………. Economy) ………. Flexibility) ………. Resilience) ………. Productivity) ………. Building Blocks of Converged IP Communications Networks) ………. Network Infrastructure) ………. Applications) ………. End Points (Client Devices) ) ………. Call Processing) ………. Major IP Communications Solutions) ………. IP Telephony) ………. Considerations for Deploying IP Telephony) ………. IP Conferencing) ………. IP Contact Centers) ………. Unified Messaging) ………. Rich Media Communications—Integrated Audio, Video, and Web Conferencing) IP Videoconferencing) ………. IP Video Telephony) ………. Extension Mobility) ………. IP Telephony Applications) ………. Mobility Applications) ………. Softphones/Soft-agents ) ………. 802.11a/b/g Wireless LANs and Wireless or Soft IP Phones ) ………. Teleworker / Support) ………. Emergency Alerting Applications ) ………. Business Continuity / Disaster Recovery) ………. Land and Mobile Radio Convergence) ………. N11 Services—211, 311, 511, 711 Services to Relieve Overburdened 911 Systems ) ………. Video/Audio-On-Demand, E-Learning) ………. A "Typical" VoIP Configuration………. The Economics of VoIP ………. Selecting......

Words: 10553 - Pages: 43


...VoIP Voice over IP Hani Aladmaai Prof. Ali Bicak IT-520: Enterprise Infra and Networks Introduction VoIP or Voice over Internet Protocol is an IP based approach to transmitting voice over a computer network. It allows a person to make voice calls using an Internet connection instead of using a phone line. The user can make phone calls free (in certain circumstances), or they may get a service provider and pay a very low rate. How VoIP works is, it converts your voice into a digital signal that will travel over the Internet. First to send voice over a digital network, it must first be converted to digital and converted back to analog at the receiving end. VoIP may allow you to make a call directly from a computer, via VoIP programs such as Skype, a special VoIP phone, or your traditional phone connected to a special adapter. The research paper will begin with an introduction as to what VoIP is, what it accomplishes, what purpose it serves and how it works; also how it is configured. Next it will discuss some of advantages and disadvantages. Legal issues will also present on the usage of the VoIP. What is VoIP? VoIP or Voice over Internet Protocol is an IP based approach to transmitting voice over a computer network. It allows a person to make voice calls using an Internet connection instead of using a phone line. The user can make phone calls free (in certain circumstances), or they may get a service provider and pay a very low rate. How does VoIP...

Words: 3847 - Pages: 16

Airline Deregulation

...Administration. (FAA) Before deregulation, innovation and change by the airline industry was smothered. It took years for airlines to petition and the CAB to approve new routes. Rates were strictly controlled. It was virtually impossible for new airlines to enter the market. Since deregulation airlines are cheaper to fly, safer, while at the same time the number of passenger miles has dramatically increased. A few facts are illuminating. Price Reductions The average fare per passenger mile is about 9% lower since deregulation. Crandall and Ellig [1] report savings of $19.4 billion per year for consumers. Contrary to conventional wisdom, the Government Accounting Office (GAO) [2] reports that, ``The average fare per passenger mile, adjusted for inflation, has fallen since deregulation about as much at airports serving small and medium-sized communities as it has at airports serving large communities.'' The theoretical possibility that deregulation would be a boon to major markets at the expense of smaller communities has proven ill founded. Improved Service Quantity Reductions in fares spurred middle class families, previously priced out of the air flight market, to fly. In 1997 airlines flew 5.7 billion miles compared to 2.5 billion in 1978. This improved service was not limited to large markets. The GAO reports that, ``The quantity of air service, as measured by the number of both departures and available seats, has increased since deregulation for all three airport......

Words: 525 - Pages: 3


...vs. at&T Skype vs At&t Case Study 1. What are the dominant economic characteristics of the VoIP Industry? PSTN charges based on minutes or even seconds while VoIP charges based on data usage. VoIP services often charge a flat fee and in Skype’s example, they offer free talk between Skype users. VoIP is also inexpensive to operate as the infrastructure is already there. VoIP is also considered part of the information service industry and not the telecommunication service industry giving it an advantage politically against PTSN (compliance with telecom laws). Against PTSN, VoIP is expected to grow substantially and is eating away at the market share of PTSN. 2. What does the five forces analysis reveal about the chances for profitability in the VoIP industry? (Prepare a five forces analysis) Threat of Substitues: Substitute for VoIP is low – as it is a substitute for PSTN Threat of New Entrants: The threat of new entrants is high in this market. As a rule in economics, companies will enter this market until there is a profit to be earned. Companies like Microsoft, Google, and AOL are just a few that are planning to compete in the VoIP market. Bargaining power of Buyers: The bargaining power is moderate because of the ease of switching to other companies. Customers are “fought for” among competitors. Bargaining Power of Suppliers: Weak- Limited bargaining power – VoIP providers are widespread and infrastructure is readily available. Net neutrality laws –......

Words: 657 - Pages: 3

Transportation Deregulation

...Dean A DeFrank Transportation Principles Embry Riddle University Module Two Deregulation All modes of travel have experienced great changes through the years. Those changes were the government getting out of the travel management business and allowing the free market to determine the course of these modes of travel. The following will describe in simplistic form the effects of deregulation on each mode of travel. Airline Deregulation: The Airline Deregulation Act of 1978 removed government control over fares, routes and creation of new airlines. The Civil Aeronautics Board (the governing body on airlines during regulation) powers of regulation were removed thus allowing the industry to be exposed to market forces. The Act, however, did not remove or diminish the regulatory powers of the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) over all aspects of air safety. Airline deregulation has enabled more competitive pricing and increased carrier flexibility. Prior to deregulation, airline pricing was regulated by the Civil Aeronautics Board. Additionally, air routes were also controlled tightly. With more freedom, carriers can offer more effective options to those who wish to use airfreight as a means of shipment. Railway deregulation: Railroad Revitalization and Regulatory Reform Act of 1976 eased regulations on rates, line abandonment, and mergers. Four years later, Congress followed up with the Staggers Rail Act of 1980. The most important features of the Staggers......

Words: 576 - Pages: 3

Globalisation Versus Anti Globalisation

...Globalization and Anti-Globalization: An Indian Perspective If one is going to talk about globalization, the term globalization must be defined. That’s the easy part. Globalization is defined as free cross-border flow of goods, services, capital, labour, information, ideas, intellectual property. Everything in fact. Defined thus, globalization is more than mere trade reform. Globalization has a descriptive component, as well as a prescriptive one, with the latter more important than the former. The former is simply a factual statement. Over a period of time, globalization has increased in importance and countries have become less insular. It is possible to argue that one encountered such globalization also in the 19th century. There are however two differences between earlier phases of globalization and the present one. First, the speed of change is faster. Second, because most flows (including capital) are private ones, governments have become less powerful in controlling or determining the shape of globalization. However, there is a prescriptive element to globalization as well. The cross-country empirical evidence is fairly robust that more open economies tend to perform better than more insulated ones. Borders are after all artificial boundaries, created by governments. They are irrelevant for purposes of efficient resource allocation. The logic of Adam Smith’s specialization and division of labour does not become any less compelling because......

Words: 3686 - Pages: 15


...Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) is a rapidly emerging technology for voice communication that uses the ubiquity of IP-based networks to deploy VoIP client devices—such as desktop IP phones, mobile VoIP-enabled handheld devices, and VoIP gateways—in an increasing number of businesses and homes around the world. Windows CE 5.0 is a robust, real-time operating system platform that enables original device manufacturers (ODMs), original equipment manufacturers (OEMs), service providers (such as Internet service providers [ISPs], cable companies, and carriers), and enterprises to rapidly develop and deploy a wide range of devices that are part of an IP network and that have integrated VoIP functionality. The latest version of Windows CE includes an integrated, easy-to-use Telephony User Interface (TUI), a VoIP Application Interface Layer (VAIL) with extensive call control functionality, an interface to access contact and calendar data on Microsoft Exchange servers, advanced provisioning capabilities, and a complete network layer stack that facilitates VoIP-enabled device development and infrastructure integration. The information contained in this document represents the current view of Microsoft Corporation on the issues discussed as of the date of publication. Because Microsoft must respond to changing market conditions, it should not be interpreted to be a commitment on the part of Microsoft, and Microsoft cannot guarantee the accuracy of any information presented after......

Words: 1932 - Pages: 8

Anti Federalists Versus Federalists

...nation. ♥ Federalists were made up of the wealthy and elite plantation owners and businessmen. ♥ The Federalists believed the articles of confederation which were the first attempt to unite the country into a continental nation had failed ♥ Cons-Anti Federalists ♥ Thought Congress held too much power. ♥ Did not like it that there was no bill of rights. ♥ Opponents of a strong central government who campaigned against the ratification of the Constitution in favor of a confederation of independent states ♥ Believe Executive Branch held too much power. ♥ Did not want the constitution Ratified ♥ Did not get their way. ♥ Anti-Federalists believed the Constitution and formation of a National Government would lead to a monarchy or aristocracy ♥ Anti-Federalists were made up mostly of farmers and tradesman, common people working to support their families. ♥ In an effort to make their argument the Anti-Federalists used rhetoric from the Revolutionary War to stress the merits of state and local government. ♥ The Anti-federalists also characterized a national or central government as a step away from democratic goals, fought for during the Revolutionary War and a step towards monarchy or aristocracy rule ♥ Anti-Federalists believed individual state rights should be protect and if the constitution was ratified states would lose their sovereignty and independent government ♥...

Words: 324 - Pages: 2


...who deserves a good deal of the credit for it, is a hero of air travel. Last week, writing about the Justice Department's move to block US Airways' planned merger with American Airlines, Mother Jones blogger Kevin Drum highlighted a novel counterargument. Mr Drum says that it is still "an open question whether deregulation was such a boon for the flying public in the first place," and points to a 2012 article by Phillip Longman and Lina Khan. In that piece, published in the Washington Monthly (where I was once an intern), Mr Longman and Ms Khan argue that airline deregulation has slowly killed mid-sized airports and the cities that depend on them. Here's the thesis: Over the years, most Americans have adopted a pretty standard line about the results [of airline deregulation]. On the one hand, complaining about the indignities of flying—overbooked, late, or cancelled flights; surly flight attendants; and, more recently, terrible in-flight food service and high fees for checked baggage— has become a staple of American life, much like complaining about Internet providers or health insurance companies. On the other hand, we’ve told ourselves, at least the increased competition has made air travel cheaper. And at least most of us can still get where we need to go by air.But now we find ourselves at a moment when nearly all the promises of the airline deregulators have clearly proved false. If you’re a member of the creative class who rarely does business in the nation’s......

Words: 895 - Pages: 4


... I. INTRODUCTION As part of its programme of work for 2006, the Joint Inspection Unit (JIU) conducted a review of selected telecommunications issues and uses of Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) technologies in United Nations system organizations. The objective of the review is to identify the opportunities for, and determine the feasibility of, using new telecommunication technologies based on VoIP in the United Nations system organizations, with a view to reducing costs and improving services. The review also analyses the coordination of telecommunication services and equipment procurement between the United Nations system organizations. In many cases, joint and coordinated telecommunication procurement/standardization could provide economies of scale and minimize costs and risks of interoperability. It could also help to attain more preferential offers from telecommunications service providers and equipment manufacturers, resulting in cheaper running costs and budget savings over the medium and long-term with assured quality of service. The review covers the telecommunication operations and practice of most of the participating organizations of JIU; the use of new telecommunication technologies, especially VoIP technologies; and the procurement of telecommunication services and equipment. Telephony is an important tool in any organization. The Inspectors note that the current systems providing telephony......

Words: 2720 - Pages: 11


...VoIP CIS 175   Telephony no longer requires a telephone with voice over IP (VoIP), a means for using the computer to transmit and receive the voice just as a telephone has been doing for a century. Some companies are shifting from PBX systems to VoIP systems, but there are a number of concerns raised by these systems that prevent many companies from making the switch, including cost considerations and issues related to the adoption of standards. VoIP has several advantages. It consolidates the voice/data network infrastructure; allows easier moves, adds, and changes to the system; and can consolidate interoffice voice traffic onto a wide area network, thus replacing off premises lines and tie lines provided by telecommunications companies. VoIP also allows easier integration of voice for call centers and other applications (Mitchell 50). Observers also note that there are a number of problems implementing VoIP, including the fact that installation costs are the same or more than for a PBX while the systems in use still lack many features found in PBXs; analog integration can be problematic; consultants with the required voice and data experience are in short supply; and standards for powering phones over Ethernet, such as call control protocols, are still evolving (Mitchell 50). A recent report on VoIP suggests that businesses might be able to cut their telecoms operating costs by half by switching to a VoIP network. The report was published by Cambridge......

Words: 1197 - Pages: 5


...VoIP and the Military Abstract The Army National Guard responsible for the safety of the State in case of a natural disaster or any sort of force that threatens the population of the State. They are also able to deploy overseas in any conflict that the United States may get involved in. Communications is on something that is very critical to the job they do and they are always looking for the newest and greatest way to accomplish their mission and do so with the best communications platforms available. Currently VoIP has been the newest and greatest thing that the Army National Guard has been able to harness. It is proving to work extremely well throughout the states due to its flexibility and reliability. But the older systems are still around because they need them as a backup in case the VoIP goes down. Ultimately the best solution would be that the VoIP never goes down. There are something in the work that will hopefully provide that avenue for the National Guard and the military as a whole. VoIP and the Military VoIP was is it? It is voice over IP and it refers to the way that phone calls are transmitted through an IP data network, whether that is on the internet or on an internal network. The reason people and especially the military are interested in VoIP is because it has the ability to help reduce expenses because the phone call travels over the network instead of a phone company’s network. Wikipedia’s definition of VoIP is “Voice over Internet......

Words: 2003 - Pages: 9


...VoIP Joseph H. Murray IT / 245 Intro to WAN October 8th, 2011 LaTrea Shine Due to frequent outages in the digital subscriber line network serving over 50 corporate-owned Gold’s Gyms; a VP Bobby Badugu knew it was about time for a significant upgrade (Desmond, 2006). He looked into a various amount of solutions including satellite, frame relay and even a different DSL provider; after carefully assessing each option he chose to go with a VoIP service. This is where his decision turned out to be a problem rather than a solution to their current issues. In the time following the decision Badugu learned some valuable lessons about not only VoIP, but major network projects that involve upgrades to numerous far-flung sites. He decided to share his insights in a presentation at the Network World IT Roadmap Conference in Dallas. Some of what he said included using a phased implementation process, establishing clear SLAs, including penalties, and conducting a thorough technology assessment to identify potential problems (Desmond, 2006). As the rollout for the change was announced it was scheduled to take only 8 weeks to complete; this was in June. In mid November while the data rollout was complete, only 20% of the voice lines have been ported over to the VoIP network (Desmond, 2006). Badugu remained headstrong to push on through expecting savings in the amount of 35 to 40 percent in voice and data service costs (Desmond, 2006). The......

Words: 397 - Pages: 2


...Codi Feuerzeig  Economics 104  Professor Robert Pollin  TA: Evelyn Kwakye  May 7, 2015     Deregulation       During the 1970s and 1980s the United States government went through a period of  deregulation.   Deregulation is a reduction of government involvement and control within an  industry.  Did this deregulation lead to the 2008 financial crisis?  This is a hot button topic that is  highly debated and causes a great deal of controversy.  The financial crisis of 2008, known as the  Great Recession, impacted the entire country and practically every individual citizen.  Many  politicians, such as Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi, look for an easy blame or a scapegoat,  for example, the deregulation by the Bush Administration.  Pelosi has been quoted saying ​ "​ the  Bush Administration's eight long years of failed deregulation policies have resulted in our  nation's largest bailout ever, leaving the American taxpayers on the hook potentially for billions  of dollars" (Gattuso).​   The issue with that statement is that the economic deregulation she speaks  of did not take place during the Bush Administration, but many years prior and the laws of that  time are not controversial in today’s economic situation.  Rather more recent regulatory laws are  to blame for the financial crisis of 2008.      Why did we Regulate in the First Place?    The Great Depression is unopposed when it comes to economic downfalls in the United  States.  The financial h...

Words: 1874 - Pages: 8